WELSH & SHEDAR | Ep. 3 | A Taste of Licorice

Credibility score: 55/100 — Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.

BSmeter analyzed "WELSH & SHEDAR | Ep. 3 | A Taste of Licorice" and rated it 55/100 for credibility (a BS score of 45/100 — mixed credibility), on 2026-11-12. Its weakest claim — "Rejette la prophétie comme une 'connerie pour les imbéciles' pour imposer sa propre autorité. 👑" — scored 20/100 and was flagged as false dilemma. 36 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.

Of 36 claims analyzed: 2 scored under 40, 21 between 40 and 69, and 13 at 70 or above.

Claims analyzed

Predicting a mother will be burned or contaminated by proximity — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 2:18

Using high-stakes words like 'burn' and 'contaminate' to describe a simple social interaction 💀

Why this score: The speaker is using heavy, almost biological metaphors to describe the danger of someone's presence. It's pure emotional weight used to justify a suspicion.

Original quote: “I don't understand why my mother keeps you so close. You'll burn or contaminate her one day.”

Se plaint de sa faiblesse en blâmant quelqu'un d'autre — la victimisation classique. 😈 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 2:30

Il se décharge de sa propre faiblesse sur les actions d'un autre. C'est la faute de l'autre, jamais la sienne. 🙄

Why this score: Le locuteur utilise un langage émotionnel pour se présenter comme une victime des actions de quelqu'un d'autre ('Si seulement elle était raisonnable... je ne serais pas devenu si faible'). C'est une tentative de détourner la responsabilité de son état actuel en blâmant une force extérieure, sans offrir de preuve ou de contexte sur la 'magie de mon Dofus' ou la 'raisonnabilité' de l'autre personne. C'est un classique pour éviter de regarder ses propres faiblesses.

Original quote: “If only she were reasonable and didn't use the magic of my Dofus as often, I wouldn't have become this weak. Truth be told, I'm now just a shadow of myself.”

Affirme que la mère doit tout à lui — une déclaration de possession sans preuve. 🚩 — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 2:45

Il balance un 'elle me doit tout' comme si c'était une vérité universelle. Où sont les reçus, mon ami ? 🧾

Why this score: Le locuteur fait une affirmation audacieuse et absolue ('Sans moi, ta mère ne serait pas ce qu'elle est aujourd'hui. Elle me doit tout') sans fournir le moindre contexte ou preuve pour étayer cette déclaration. C'est une tentative de s'attribuer un mérite ou une influence démesurée, en parlant avec une certitude qui n'est pas justifiée par les informations partagées. C'est une tactique pour établir une hiérarchie ou un sentiment de dette sans avoir à prouver quoi que ce soit.

Original quote: “Without me, your mother wouldn't be who she is today. She owes me everything,”

Décrit le frère comme un manipulateur qui mélange vérités et mensonges — la recette classique de la désinformation. 😈 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 3:30

Il dit que son frère 'mélange quelques vérités parmi mille mensonges'. C'est le manuel du parfait manipulateur, ça. 🐍

Why this score: Le locuteur décrit les actions de son frère ('Il est malin. Il s'immisce dans ton esprit, disperse quelques vérités parmi mille mensonges') pour discréditer toute information provenant de lui. C'est un exemple de langage chargé qui vise à peindre le frère comme un manipulateur sournois, rendant toute 'vision' ou 'prémonition' suspecte. C'est une technique pour semer le doute et contrôler la perception de l'interlocuteur, en utilisant des mots qui évoquent la tromperie et la manipulation.

Original quote: “My brother, Dardondakal, is the one who sent you that vision. What are you saying? He's clever. He pops into your mind, scatters a few truths among a thousand lies,”

Rejette la prophétie comme une 'connerie pour les imbéciles' pour imposer sa propre autorité. 👑 — False Dilemma (20/100)

At 3:45

Il te dit de rejeter la prophétie pour n'écouter que la volonté de ta mère. C'est soit l'un, soit l'autre, pas de place pour le libre arbitre. ⛓️

Why this score: Le locuteur crée un faux dilemme en opposant la 'prophétie et la connerie du destin' (qu'il attribue aux 'imbéciles') à la 'volonté de ta mère' comme seule chose qui compte. Il ne laisse aucune place à d'autres perspectives ou à la possibilité de concilier différentes influences. C'est une tentative de simplifier une situation complexe en deux options mutuellement exclusives, forçant l'interlocuteur à choisir son camp et à rejeter toute autre source d'information ou de motivation.

Original quote: “So leave the prophecy and destiny bunk to fools. Don't fall for it. Only your mother's will matters. Don't forget that.”

Sources: Gardez-vous des faux prophètes, partie 2, Le faux prophète de l'Apocalypse - AgoraVox le média citoyen, Vraies et fausses prophéties : comment discerner ? - Aleteia

Propose une alternative 'humaine' à l'assassinat, mais c'est toujours une prison. 💀 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 4:00

Il demande si l'emprisonnement est plus 'humain' que le meurtre. C'est un choix entre la peste et le choléra, pas une solution. 🤷‍♂️

Why this score: L'interlocuteur utilise le mot 'humain' pour décrire l'emprisonnement comme une alternative au meurtre, ce qui est un exemple de langage chargé. Bien que l'emprisonnement soit sans doute moins violent que le meurtre, le fait de le qualifier d''humain' dans ce contexte tente de le présenter comme une solution moralement supérieure sans aborder les implications éthiques de priver quelqu'un de sa liberté, surtout s'il est 'de la famille'. C'est une tentative de rendre une option difficile plus acceptable en utilisant un terme émotionnellement positif.

Original quote: “It's just, this boy is family. He's my cousin. Couldn't we lock him up instead of killing him?”

Claiming kingship requires 'difficult decisions' for the 'greater good' — heavy-handed moralizing 🎭 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 4:38

Using high-stakes buzzwords like 'greater good' to justify a king's burden. Pure dramatic fluff 🎭

Why this score: The speaker uses heavy, moralistic terminology to frame the burden of leadership as a noble sacrifice without any actual context of what those 'decisions' are.

Original quote: “You need to understand that ruling a kingdom means making difficult decisions for the greater good.”

Demanding respect through a demand for 'true appearance' — authority play 👑 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 5:26

Demanding a specific visual standard just to be spoken to. That's not leadership, that's an ego trip 💀

Why this score: The character is using a demand for visual authenticity as a way to assert dominance and force the other person to comply with their personal standards.

Original quote: “I'd like you to keep your true appearance when you address me.”

Using 'scent' as a tracking method to justify an assassination mission 🩸 — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 5:59

Using a scent as 'proof' to launch an execution mission. High confidence, zero actual evidence 🩸

Why this score: The speaker presents the identification of a target based solely on 'scent' as a definitive fact to justify an immediate mission of elimination.

Original quote: “He has the same scent as the queen and prince. Find him for me and eliminate him.”

Calling an omelet a 'feast' and 'classy' — high-key loaded language 🎭 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 7:35

Using 'classy' and 'feast' to describe a single omelet. That's just dramatic flair for no reason 💀

Why this score: The speaker uses elevated, hyperbolic adjectives to describe a very basic meal, attempting to manufacture importance through tone.

Original quote: “Well, isn't that classy! Our little king sure has served up a feast!”

Claiming 'gobbowl' is an excuse for everything — pure vibes 💨 — Just Vibes (50/100)

At 7:59

Using a game as a catch-all excuse. It's not logic, it's just nonsense for the plot 🙄

Why this score: This is a character-driven comedic beat rather than a factual claim, using the game 'gobbowl' as a convenient conversational pivot.

Original quote: “Exactly. Gobbowl players have to be careful not to have too much gas in their stomachs.”

Une petite blague sur les chats et la famille — juste des "vibes" d'intro. — Just Vibes (50/100)

At 8:30

Un peu de comédie pour briser la glace. Pas de mensonge, juste un chat qui persécute. 😈

Why this score: C'est une conversation légère, une blague sur un chat et les liens familiaux. Il n'y a aucune affirmation factuelle à vérifier, juste de l'humour pour lancer l'épisode.

Original quote: “Is that furball really your cat? Yes. His name is Kitt. Mama says that he's been watching over me and following me since I was born. Me, I would say it's more like he's been persecuting me since I was born. But as they say, you can't choose your family!”

Le narrateur établit un univers fantastique avec des reines, des dragons et des royaumes — c'est de la pure narration. — No Frame (75/100)

At 8:57

Il pose les bases de son monde imaginaire. Pas de mensonge ici, juste une histoire qui se déroule. 😈

Why this score: Le locuteur est en train de raconter une histoire dans un univers fictif, décrivant des personnages, des lieux et des événements qui lui sont propres. Il n'y a pas de prétention à la réalité, c'est de la pure fiction narrative.

Original quote: “It's more yours than mine, Welsh. Our enemy is the powerful Zabelle. The black queen. She reigns over two nations, Amakna and Bonta. And is probably one of the most powerful beings in the world. They call her the black queen because she is linked with the black dragon, Grougalorasalar. "Asalar" to…”

Setting the stage for a fantasy battle — just narrative setup. — No Frame (75/100)

At 10:31

Just the setup for the story, nothing to dissect here. Pure narrative. 😈

Why this score: This is simply establishing the premise of the conflict within the fictional world. There's no persuasive framing or factual claim to analyze, just storytelling.

Original quote: “To defeat them, Zabelle and Kannell each had to get a Dofus as well. The battle was long, bitter and bloody, but our enemies were defeated.”

Narrating the aftermath of victory and the beginning of divergence. — No Frame (75/100)

At 10:43

More world-building, setting up the conflict to come. Still just story. 😈

Why this score: The speaker is continuing the narrative, describing the consequences of the battle and introducing the differing approaches of the two characters, which will drive the plot. No manipulative framing is present.

Original quote: “The heroes were acclaimed and crowned king and queen of Bonta and Amakna. The two kingdoms were at peace for just over ten years. But the two did not use their Dofus in the same way.”

Contrasting two characters' approaches to power — a classic narrative trope. — No Frame (75/100)

At 10:58

The classic 'good twin, evil twin' setup. Predictable, but it's just story. 😈

Why this score: This segment establishes a clear contrast between Kannell's cautious use of power and Zabelle's unrestrained application, a common narrative device to build character and conflict. It's purely descriptive within the story's context.

Original quote: “Kannell understood that drawing on the power of a Dofus cut both ways. Zabelle, however, set no limits. Holder of the Ebony Dofus, she used its magic for everything. Making crops grow faster, forging magical weapons.”

Describing Zabelle's descent into corruption and lust for power. — No Frame (75/100)

At 11:17

The villain arc is in full swing. Standard fantasy fare. 😈

Why this score: The narrative details Zabelle's transformation and growing ambition, leading to her desire for domination. This is a direct plot point, not a claim requiring external verification or a manipulative frame.

Original quote: “An irreversible link grew progressively between her and Asalar. In the end, the queen and the dragon were one. Insidiously, Zabelle's thoughts turned ever more to domination, and she sought to take her brother's kingdom for herself.”

Kannell's plea for reconciliation and a peaceful resolution. — No Frame (75/100)

At 11:28

The hero's desperate plea to the corrupted sibling. Seen it a million times. 😈

Why this score: Kannell's dialogue expresses a desire for a peaceful resolution and appeals to their shared past, a common element in conflict narratives. It's an emotional appeal within the story, not a factual claim.

Original quote: “Zabelle, my beloved sister, there are other ways. Let's walk on the ramparts like we did as children and find a solution! Please, Zabelle, it's not too late to get on the right track.”

Zabelle's fatalistic acceptance of her corrupted state, contrasting Kannell's hope. — No Frame (75/100)

At 11:57

She's embraced the darkness. The 'too far gone' trope. Classic. 😈

Why this score: Zabelle's lines reflect her internal struggle and acceptance of her current, corrupted state, rejecting Kannell's attempts at redemption. This is character development and dialogue, not a claim to be fact-checked.

Original quote: “Kannell, calling on the past is useless. I can only see what I have become. I've failed, I admit. I should have listened long ago. But I've always been too stubborn. Please, Zabelle, it's not too late to get on the right track.”

Kannell's final, desperate challenge to Zabelle. — No Frame (75/100)

At 12:12

The gloves are off. The inevitable clash. Just a story beat. 😈

Why this score: This is a dramatic line of dialogue, signaling the impending confrontation between the two characters. It's a narrative element, not a claim that can be framed manipulatively or verified.

Original quote: “Please, do not hold back in this fight!”

Just enjoying the moment — no hidden agenda here. — Just Vibes (50/100)

At 12:36

He's just reveling in the simple joy of using his Dofus. No grand pronouncements, just pure, unadulterated fun. 😈

Why this score: This is a character expressing personal enjoyment, not making a factual claim or trying to persuade. It's a moment of pure, unburdened emotion, which is rare and almost refreshing in its simplicity. It's a character beat, nothing more, nothing less.

Original quote: “I don't get to use my Dofus every day. It's very exhilarating.”

Establishing lore and character backstory with magical elements. — No Frame (75/100)

At 12:43

Laying out the magical rules of their world. It's world-building, not a lie. 😈

Why this score: This is exposition within a fictional narrative, establishing the magical abilities of a character's clan and the nature of their parents' bond. These are internal facts of the story's universe, not claims about the real world. It's straightforward storytelling.

Original quote: “She had the powers of her own clan, the Bellaphones. Your parents' love for each other had been sealed by a powerful spell.”

Setting up a dramatic magical bond with high stakes. — No Frame (75/100)

At 13:01

Defining the terms of their magical connection. It's a clear, if dramatic, plot device. 😈

Why this score: This is a crucial piece of narrative information, establishing the magical bond between the parents and its dire consequences. It's a fictional premise designed to create tension and stakes within the story, not a claim to be fact-checked against reality. It's a clear statement of the rules of their world.

Original quote: “They shared all their pains, and all their thoughts. Their communion was absolute. So absolute that if one were to die, the other would die within minutes.”

Emphasizing the high stakes of the battle through emotional connection. — Emotional Button (45/100)

At 13:19

They're not just stating facts; they're twisting the knife of consequence to make you feel the weight. 💀

Why this score: While technically true within the narrative's established rules, the phrasing 'depended on his victory as well' is designed to heighten emotional investment. It uses the vulnerability of the wife and unborn child to amplify the drama and make the audience care more about the outcome, rather than just presenting the information neutrally.

Original quote: “Kannell wasn't fighting for himself alone. The lives of his wife and future child depended on his victory as well.”

A clear, direct threat of lethal intent. — No Frame (75/100)

At 13:50

No ambiguity here. This character means business. 😈

Why this score: This is a direct declaration of intent from one character to another within the narrative. It's a straightforward threat, serving to advance the plot and define the antagonist's motivation. There's no hidden meaning or manipulative framing; it's simply stating a clear objective.

Original quote: “Know that I absolutely intend to take your life, Kannell! And I won't leave until I've done so!”

A character experiencing the pain of childbirth through a magical bond. — No Frame (75/100)

At 14:03

He's just reacting to the magical link they established earlier. It's consistent. 😈

Why this score: This is a direct consequence of the previously established magical bond between the parents. The character is experiencing and reacting to the pain of childbirth through this link, which is consistent with the internal logic of the story. It's a character moment, not a factual claim.

Original quote: “Remember, I feel everything, my dear. So this is what women endure during birth?”

The setup for a classic hero's journey — the hidden past, the waiting guardian. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)

At 17:18

Ah, the old 'hidden until you're ready' trope. I've seen this play out since before written language. 🎭

Why this score: This is pure narrative setup, establishing the protagonist's backstory within the fictional world. It's a common storytelling device, not a claim to be fact-checked. It's just setting the scene for the drama to unfold.

Original quote: “I left you in the care of General Marmite. I was waiting until you came of age before coming to get you.”

Hiding the truth 'for protection' — the oldest excuse for keeping secrets. 💀 — Loaded Language (45/100)

At 17:31

They always say 'for your protection' when they mean 'because it was convenient for us.' It's a classic manipulation. 🔥

Why this score: The phrase 'purely to protect you' is loaded language designed to evoke sympathy and justify past actions without offering concrete reasons. It frames the deception as a benevolent act, rather than acknowledging the potential harm or distrust caused by withholding information.

Original quote: “You must understand, we hid your true origins from you purely to protect you.”

The 'unique trait' as the giveaway — a convenient plot device. 🚩 — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 17:52

A 'unique shade of blue' is the big reveal? And 'must have noticed' is their proof? That's not evidence, that's a guess. 🙄

Why this score: The speaker presents a hypothesis ('Someone in Brassica must have noticed and warned her') as if it's a confirmed explanation for how the secret was discovered. There's no actual evidence provided, just a confident assertion based on a supposed 'unique trait.' This is a mismatch between the certainty of the claim and the lack of supporting information.

Original quote: “In your family, your eyes are a unique shade of blue. Someone in Brassica must have noticed and warned her.”

The kid's dramatic plea about being slaughtered — pure emotional button-pushing. 😈 — Emotional Button (45/100)

At 18:30

He's not just 'a kid,' he's a prince. This is a classic 'pity me' play to avoid responsibility. 💀

Why this score: Using exaggerated language like 'slaughtered' and emphasizing his youth to evoke sympathy and avoid a difficult situation. It's a transparent attempt to manipulate the listener's emotions rather than present a logical argument.

Original quote: “You seem to forget I'm just a kid! You'll send me to be slaughtered!”

Blaming the advisor for his parents' death — a low blow and a classic straw man. 🔥 — Straw Man (20/100)

At 18:40

He's twisting the advisor's role into a direct cause of death. That's not how advice works, kid. 😈

Why this score: The speaker is creating a false connection between the advisor's past role and the parents' demise. It's an unfair accusation that attacks a distorted version of the advisor's influence, rather than addressing the current situation.

Original quote: “If you really were my parents' advisor, it's no surprise they are both dead!”

Minimizing the burden of kingship — a confidence mismatch from someone who isn't king. 💀 — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 19:00

Easy to say when you're not the one wearing the crown. That's not wisdom, that's just talk. 😈

Why this score: The speaker is confidently asserting that being a king isn't so bad, despite not having that experience themselves. It's a dismissive statement that lacks the necessary understanding or empathy for the actual weight of such a role.

Original quote: “There are worse things than finding out you're a king.”

Revealing a tragic backstory to build empathy — a classic emotional button. 😈 — Emotional Button (45/100)

At 19:10

A sob story to make you feel for him. It's effective, I'll give him that. 💀

Why this score: The speaker is sharing a personal tragedy involving the 'black queen's path' and the attack on Bonta to elicit sympathy and understanding from the listener. This is a direct appeal to emotion to influence the listener's perspective.

Original quote: “I've always said that I was an orphan, but what you don't know is that my village was along the black queen's path when she attacked Bonta.”

Describing the devastation and his escape — more emotional button-pushing. 🔥 — Emotional Button (45/100)

At 19:20

Painting a picture of total loss and personal escape. It's designed to make you connect with his trauma. 😈

Why this score: The detailed description of losing 'everything' and the necessity of running away is intended to amplify the emotional impact of his story. It's a narrative crafted to generate strong feelings of pity and shared experience.

Original quote: “They took everything from us. All our food and the men able to fight. I ran away as soon as I had the chance.”

Offering unwavering support after a tragic story — a calculated emotional appeal. 💀 — Emotional Button (45/100)

At 19:40

After all that, he's offering loyalty. It's a powerful move, tying his trauma to his commitment. 😈

Why this score: Following a deeply emotional personal story, the speaker offers to join Welsh on an adventure, framing it as an act of courage despite his past. This leverages the emotional weight of his narrative to solidify his commitment and influence Welsh's decision.

Original quote: “What I'm trying to say, Welsh, is if you go on this adventure, I'm not afraid to go with you.”

Claiming knowledge of mistreatment through spying — anonymous authority and loaded language. 🚩 — Anonymous Authority (45/100)

At 20:20

He 'learned' by spying, then declares 'mistreatment.' That's not evidence, that's an accusation based on eavesdropping. 💀

Why this score: The speaker claims to know about the father's 'mistreatment' through spying, which is an unreliable and potentially biased source of information. The term 'mistreats' is loaded language, presenting a subjective interpretation as fact without concrete evidence or context.

Original quote: “I learned of you by spying on your father. He mistreats you.”

See the full analysis with sources and timestamps →