A New Star Wars Movie Comes Out This Week… Nobody Cares
Credibility score: 50/100 — Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.
BSmeter analyzed "A New Star Wars Movie Comes Out This Week… Nobody Cares" and rated it 50/100 for credibility (a BS score of 50/100 — mixed credibility), on 2026-05-21. Its weakest claim — "Mandalorian & Grogu has the lowest Star Wars opening weekend ever" — scored 40/100 and was flagged as dubious. 11 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Of 11 claims analyzed: 0 scored under 40, 11 between 40 and 69, and 0 at 70 or above.
Claims analyzed
Star Wars movies used to be huge cultural events but now nobody cares — Opinion (50/100)
At 0:05
Nostalgia filter on full blast — past hype always feels bigger than current reality.
Why this score: Classic cultural commentary. The speaker contrasts past Star Wars excitement with today's apparent indifference.
- This is a subjective take on pop culture fatigue rather than a verifiable fact.
- Many fans still get excited, but social media reactions can feel muted compared to 1999 or 2015.
- Hard to quantify "nobody cares" when box office and online buzz vary by film.
Original quote: “There was a time when a new Star Wars movie felt like a global event. You remember it? Toys vanished off shelves. People lined up outside theaters for days. Every commercial break had a lightsaber in it. Star Wars releases used to feel like history happening in real time. Now we are in release week…”
Mandalorian & Grogu has the lowest Star Wars opening weekend ever — Dubious (40/100)
At 0:30
Grogu movie isn't even out yet in May 2026 — hard to call it the lowest anything.
Why this score: Timeline issue. The Mandalorian & Grogu film is scheduled for 2026, not released this week.
- No opening weekend numbers exist yet
- Recent Star Wars theatrical releases have indeed struggled compared to earlier films
- Premature to rank an unreleased movie as having the lowest opening
Original quote: “The Mandalorian and Grogo was released this week and is set for the lowest opening weekend of any Star Wars film ever.”
Says seven years since last Star Wars movie on big screen — OK (60/100)
At 2:30
Close but off by a few years — the timeline's stretched a bit.
Why this score: The last theatrical Star Wars film before this new one was indeed The Rise of Skywalker in 2019. Seven years from 2019 lands in 2026, which fits the current date. But the video is speaking in present tense about a film releasing 'this week' so the gap feels slightly exaggerated for effect.
Original quote: “It's been seven years since the Star Wars franchises visited a galaxy far, far away on the big screen. In December 2019, The Rise of Skywalker, the third and final film in the franchise's sequel trilogy, was released, earning a little over a billion dollars worldwide.”
Low investment if you skip the TV show — Opinion (50/100)
At 4:30
Classic 'you had to be there' problem for franchise films.
Why this score: Fair point but it cuts both ways. - The interconnected universe clearly rewards long-time fans - Casual viewers often feel lost in these stories - Harrison is pointing out a real tension between depth and accessibility
Original quote: “Harrison tells the BBC, "If you're not familiar with the TV show, you've got such low investment going to see it."”
Disney spent $187M on The Acolyte — Dubious (45/100)
At 6:30
The $187M figure is widely reported but Disney never officially confirmed it.
Why this score: Commonly cited but unverified by Disney.
- Multiple outlets reported the $187 million budget
- Disney has not publicly confirmed or denied the number
- Exact production costs for streaming shows are rarely disclosed
Original quote: “It's $187 million. How many more resources do you need to throw at the damn thing to see if it sticks? This is Disney. They have infinite resources.”
Good story matters more than practical effects or authenticity — Opinion (50/100)
At 8:49
Fair take — story quality usually beats production tricks, though audiences still notice when effects feel cheap.
Why this score: Opinion on film priorities.
- Speaker correctly notes that audiences have rejected overly fake CGI before
- Emphasizes story over technical method, which aligns with what most viewers actually say they want
- Ignores that practical effects can still enhance a strong story rather than compete with it
Original quote: “this article kind of contradicts itself. that whole narrative of authenticity still have the audience. We still care about the story. I don't care if a good film is shot digitally on film in your bathroom. If it's a good story, we'll all watch it.”
Mandalorian & Grogu spin-off doesn't feel like real event cinema — Opinion (50/100)
At 9:14
Valid skepticism — spin-offs from TV shows rarely get treated like must-see theatrical events by casual fans.
Why this score: Early reception to Mandalorian & Grogu.
- The film is positioned as a big-screen version of a streaming series, which changes audience expectations
- Disney has a pattern of calling every new Star Wars project 'the next big thing' while previous ones underperform
- Whether it lands as event cinema will depend on word-of-mouth rather than marketing alone
Original quote: “As Star Wars tries to reclaim now some of its cinematic magic, it's clear the Mandalorian Grou may have not been the best title to come out of the block with. The Lucasfilm hasn't quite convinced early viewers that as a spin-off from a TV show, the film qualifies as the kind of event cinema that is…”
Disney keeps promising the next Star Wars movie will fix everything — Just Vibes (50/100)
At 9:34
Classic Disney Star Wars cycle — every release gets sold as the one that finally gets it right.
Why this score: Pattern of repeated 'next film' hype.
- This matches the post-Force Awakens cycle where each new project was positioned as a reset
- The 'mystery box' approach has been criticized for years as a way to keep interest alive without delivering
- Audiences have grown tired of the endless 'wait for the next one' messaging
Original quote: “Isn't everything that's next the great new hope? Like everything that comes out from Disney Star Wars is this isn't great, but wait till the next one. That's going to hook you forever. And then the next one comes out. Oh, no. Don't worry about this one. It's the next one you want.”
Disney and media dismissed all Star Wars criticism as toxic fandom — Opinion (50/100)
At 10:30
Classic framing — paints every critique as bad-faith without addressing why some landed.
Why this score: Broad generalization about media response. Key points:
- Some outlets did label certain backlash as toxic, especially around *The Last Jedi*
- Other criticism was treated as legitimate debate, not dismissed outright
- This paints the entire conversation as corporate gaslighting rather than mixed coverage
Original quote: “For years, every criticism of Disney Star Wars got brushed aside as toxic fandom, rage bait, or people refusing to move on.”
Says Mandalorian Season 1 was the best and simplest — Opinion (50/100)
At 12:30
Totally fair take — a lot of people still call Season 1 peak Mandalorian.
Why this score: Opinion, not a fact check. Many fans agree Season 1 felt fresh and standalone before the show got tangled in crossover plots. No data needed here — it's a common sentiment among Star Wars viewers.
Original quote: “The Mandalorian was great in the beginning. It was the closest thing to modern Star Wars that had goodwill. Season 1 worked because it was simple.”
George Lucas made Star Wars special and now there's zero hype for the new movie — Opinion (50/100)
At 14:30
Fair point about Lucas-era magic, but 'zero hype' is the part that needs receipts.
Why this score: Opinion about what makes Star Wars feel special. Key points:
- Lucas is credited with creating the cohesive universe and cultural phenomenon
- The speaker contrasts this with current Disney-era output
- No specific viewership or social metrics are given to support 'zero hype'
Original quote: “Say what you want about George Lucas, but George Lucas understood how to tie it all together, make it feel special, and take the money out of your wallet at the same time. This whole situation is so blatantly obvious that the BBC had to chime in because fans, we've been saying this stuff for years.…”
See the full analysis with timestamps →