The BIG Problem With Game Theory

Credibility score: 49/100 โ€” Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.

BSmeter analyzed "The BIG Problem With Game Theory" and rated it 49/100 for credibility (a BS score of 51/100 โ€” mixed credibility), on 2026-09-24. Its weakest claim โ€” "Admits small sample size as a limitation of his experiment" โ€” scored 45/100 and was flagged as missing context. 30 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.

Of 30 claims analyzed: 0 scored under 40, 27 between 40 and 69, and 3 at 70 or above.

Claims analyzed

Opening with viewer comparisons to other creators โ€” a bit of self-deprecating humor. โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 0:00

He's just leaning into the comments, trying to build rapport. Harmless fluff. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

Why this score: This isn't a claim, it's just the speaker acknowledging viewer feedback and making a joke. It's pure entertainment, not meant to persuade or inform with facts.

Original quote: โ€œHey, y'all. Neil Cicierega here. According to the comment section of part one, you guys think I look like Neil Cicierega, Scott the Woz, and a little bit of Bo Burnham. Better let Bo Burnham, burn 'em.โ€

Bragging about a previous video's success โ€” a classic ego boost. โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 0:11

He's just basking in the glow of his last hit. Nothing to fact-check, just a mortal enjoying their fleeting moment. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

Why this score: The speaker is celebrating the success of a previous video. This is a personal statement about his channel's performance, not a factual claim about game theory itself. It's a common way creators build credibility or simply share their excitement.

Original quote: โ€œI uploaded a video called Game Theory has gotten worse, and I can kind of prove it. And oh my god, the reception that video has gotten. That is my most viewed video today, and I am so unbelievably thankful for the response I've gotten. There's so many positive comments eitherโ€

Admits small sample size as a limitation of his experiment โ€” Missing Context (45/100)

At 1:28

Admits the data is thin because he was caught off guard by his own success ๐Ÿ“‰

Why this score: He's explicitly calling out the lack of scale in his previous 'experiment,' which means the conclusions drawn from it were never meant to be universal.

Original quote: โ€œthe sample pool I picked for the videos was very small because it was a very small-scale experiment, and again, wasn't expecting it to blow up.โ€

Admits to using an outlier that lacked community context โ€” Missing Context (45/100)

At 1:59

Calls himself out for using a niche reference that didn't land with the audience ๐Ÿšฉ

Why this score: He realizes he used a specific piece of content as an example without ensuring the audience actually understood the context, making his critique feel arbitrary.

Original quote: โ€œit wasn't fair of me to include the Chica's Secret Party video. No one in the FNAF community knows what this is, so it wasn't fair enough for me to criticize it by saying it didn't come to a conclusion.โ€

Claims the channel declined because MatPat sold out and made 'fun' theories he didn't believe ๐Ÿ“‰ โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 2:42

Uses 'decline' and 'sold it to the company' as emotional triggers for a structural shift ๐Ÿšฉ

Why this score: He's using the corporate transition and the 'fun vs belief' narrative to frame a period of decline without explaining the actual business or content shifts that caused it.

Original quote: โ€œGame Theory, even before MatPat left, was slowly heading towards the decline because when MatPat was in charge, he sold it to the company... Some of the theories that MatPat made, he didn't personally believe, and he was doing it for fun.โ€

Uses a host's nationality as an argument against criticizing them ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง โ€” False Equivalence (45/100)

At 3:50

Equates being British with being un-rag-able. That's a reach ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: He makes a logical leap that nationality serves as a shield against criticism, which is a playful but structurally weak argument to justify his personal liking of the hosts.

Original quote: โ€œI personally really like some of the hosts. I think some of them are entertaining. And I mean, come on, he's British. You can't rag on him that hard. That's problematic.โ€

Claims his video was 'unbelievably' successful and loved by everyone ๐Ÿš€ โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 4:13

Purely emotional hype about his own success. No data, just vibes โ˜๏ธ

Why this score: This is a standard creator 'thank you' moment. It's not a factual claim about viewership numbers, just him expressing his high of the moment.

Original quote: โ€œI want to thank you all so much for the love and support that you have showed to that video. It's genuinely rocketed me to the sky.โ€

Admits to calling a company a 'community' because it sounded better โ€” Missing Context (45/100)

At 4:42

Admits he was selling a vibe instead of the reality. Pure branding over substance ๐Ÿšฉ

Why this score: He openly admits he used the word 'community' because it 'sounded cool,' which is a classic case of using emotional branding to mask the corporate reality of the entity.

Original quote: โ€œAs most of you pointed out, Game Theory is a company. I said that Game Theory was a community and not a company because it rang true in my mind at the time, and it also sounded pretty cool. I had completely forgotten that Game Theory, and in turn Theorist Media, was sold off to Lunar X December 20,โ€ฆโ€

Claims the sale was about maintaining quality and family time โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 5:55

Uses 'family time' and 'maintaining quality' to mask the business mechanics of a massive sale ๐ŸŽญ

Why this score: He's framing a corporate acquisition as a wholesome lifestyle choice. It's easy to say he wanted 'time with family,' but it ignores the actual business motivations behind selling a massive media empire.

Original quote: โ€œMatthew Patrick sold theorist media to Lunar X December 20th, 2022. He believed that they could help by maintaining our quality or be able to better it. After 13 years of game theory, Matt Pat just kind of wanted to spend time with his family and make more room for his kids.โ€

Claims company leadership is 'run by Satan' as a dramatic setup ๐Ÿ˜ˆ โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 6:49

Using 'Satan' and 'the devil' to describe corporate leadership is pure theatrical flair ๐ŸŽญ

Why this score: He uses heavy-handed religious imagery to create a sense of mystery and menace around the company's management before even presenting facts.

Original quote: โ€œWhen I first heard about Lunar X, aka in my comment section, it sounded like it was run by Satan himself. Well, that could be true. I didn't know the devil's name was Lucas Coleman. Disclaimer, I am not calling Lucas Coleman or anyone involved with Lunar X the devil.โ€

Accusing YouTube of predatory corporate exploitation via loaded questions โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 9:19

Using rhetorical questions to mask a heavy critique of corporate greed ๐Ÿšฉ

Why this score: He's using 'It's not like...' to frame a massive, controversial claim about corporate exploitation as if it were an obvious truth he's just 'not mentioning.' It's pure emotional manipulation through sarcasm.

Original quote: โ€œI mean, it's not like the current business model of YouTube and its monetization feature is to prey on little kids who can't tell slop from not slop, right? It's not like a bunch of corporations are using YouTube content as a way to squeeze money out of these children and exploiting theโ€ฆโ€

Claiming a specific date for unionization due to declining conditions โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 9:52

Framing a corporate labor shift as an 'infamous' historical event ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: He uses high-stakes, dramatic language like 'a day that will live in infamy' for a standard labor unionization process. It's massive confidence applied to a specific corporate timeline that feels more like editorial flair than hard reporting.

Original quote: โ€œNovember 13th, 2025. A day that will live in infamy. Employees of Theorist Media and intern Lunar X have decided to unionize after a constant decline in working conditions.โ€

Declares 'probably not' without a shred of evidence. Just vibes. ๐Ÿ’€ โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 10:46

Predicts the future with absolute certainty, but offers zero basis for it. That's not a prediction, it's a shrug. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

Why this score: The speaker states 'Probably not' regarding whether Lunar X will voluntarily recognize their workers. This is presented as a confident prediction of corporate behavior without any supporting evidence, analysis of the company's past actions, or market trends. It's a gut feeling presented as an informed conclusion.

Original quote: โ€œProbably not.โ€

Uses 'awful,' 'ludicrous,' and 'insane' to describe deadlines. Pure emotional button. ๐Ÿšฉ โ€” Emotional Button (45/100)

At 11:12

He's hitting all the outrage words without explaining *why* they're awful or insane. That's not a critique, it's a feeling. ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: The speaker uses highly emotive and subjective terms ('awful,' 'ludicrous,' 'insane') to describe the deadlines without providing specific examples or objective criteria for why they are so. This language is intended to trigger an emotional response of agreement and outrage from the viewer, rather than presenting a factual, evidence-based argument about the unreasonableness of the deadlines. It's an appeal to shared sentiment.

Original quote: โ€œthis is awful for a number of reasons and the deadlines some of these people have to follow are ludicrous [music] and insane.โ€

Admits his experiment isn't 'great' but insists the results are 'interesting.' A classic volume game. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ โ€” Volume Game (45/100)

At 11:58

He downplays the experiment's quality, then immediately hypes the 'interesting' results. That's how you soften the blow before the big reveal. ๐Ÿ’

Why this score: The speaker employs a 'volume game' by first acknowledging a weakness in his methodology ('this isn't a great example') which preemptively disarms criticism. Immediately after, he pivots to emphasizing the 'very interesting' results, hoping the initial admission of weakness will make the audience more receptive to the findings, regardless of the experiment's actual rigor. It's a rhetorical trick to manage expectations and maintain engagement.

Original quote: โ€œI know this isn't a great example, but it is an example, and the results I got are very interesting.โ€

Confesses to being 'very loose' with judgment. Another preemptive strike. ๐Ÿ’€ โ€” Volume Game (45/100)

At 12:28

He's telling you his judgment was 'loose' right before presenting his findings. That's not transparency, it's an excuse in advance. ๐Ÿ”ฅ

Why this score: Similar to the previous point, the speaker again uses a 'volume game' by admitting a significant limitation ('very loose with how I judged these') right before presenting his experimental results. This serves as a pre-emptive defense against potential criticism of his conclusions, allowing him to present his findings while simultaneously creating an alibi for any perceived flaws. It's a way to manage the audience's perception of the validity of his upcoming 'interesting' results.

Original quote: โ€œThen again, I was very loose with how I judged these, so bear that in mind.โ€

Sets up the experiment with a disclaimer about memory and loose judgment. โ€” No Frame (75/100)

At 12:30

He's upfront about the subjective nature of his 'experiment' and its potential flaws. At least he's honest about it. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

Why this score: The speaker explicitly states that his judgment was 'very loose,' that red herrings were present, and that both the art and theories were recounted 'via memory,' blaming the 'human brain' if anything seems wrong. This is a clear, self-aware disclaimer, setting appropriate expectations for the audience rather than trying to hide potential inaccuracies.

Original quote: โ€œThen again, I was very loose with how I judgedย  these, so bear that in mind. I also had to deal with red herrings in the experiment,ย  placed throughout to throw me off course, much like anything will appear in a game or a filmย  when you're trying to solve the lore. Shoutout to my wonderfulโ€ฆโ€

Misreads 'cat fingers' as 'rest in peace' and reacts to his own mistake. โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 13:48

He's just reacting to his own misreading. A classic mortal blunder, nothing more. ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: The speaker is simply misinterpreting on-screen text ('cat fingers' vs. 'rest in peace') and reacting to his own error. This is a moment of lighthearted self-deprecation and not a claim intended to persuade or mislead, falling squarely into the 'just vibes' category.

Original quote: โ€œI did She's mad at mobile games. I thoughtย  this said rest in peace. I'm so done for.โ€

Just a flurry of disconnected phrases and names โ€” pure chaos, no real claims. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 14:30

He's just throwing out game terms and social media handles. It's a stream of consciousness, not a statement. ๐Ÿคทโ€โ™€๏ธ

Why this score: This segment is a rapid-fire series of game-related terms, character names, and a social media reference. There's no coherent claim being made, just a chaotic introduction or a moment of playful confusion. It's not meant to be fact-checked, just observed.

Original quote: โ€œSurvey program my Deltarune. Chris and Azriel. The Rudebuster. Noel heart Azriel. Click my link just you wait on twitter.com. I'm [ __ ] I don't know what any of this means.โ€

Declares Susie will kill Noelle based on 'things I've heard' โ€” that's not evidence, that's gossip. ๐Ÿ’€ โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 15:22

He's making a definitive prediction about a game's plot from 'things I've heard' and two minutes of 'evidence.' That's not a conclusion, that's a guess with a crown. ๐Ÿ‘‘

Why this score: The speaker states a definitive conclusion ('Susie will kill Noelle') based on 'things I've heard' and a rushed, two-minute analysis of 'prophecy panels.' The confidence in the conclusion far outweighs the stated basis of the evidence, which is anecdotal and time-constrained. He admits he was 'stressed' and 'throwing things together.'

Original quote: โ€œWith two minutes and the evidence was provided, I came to the conclusion that in Deltarune, Susie will kill Noelle. In Deltarune, the prophecy panels depict a monster and a girl. I immediately came to the conclusion that the monster must be Susie and the girl must be Noelle. This was purely basedโ€ฆโ€

Admits his 'conclusion' was rushed, poorly researched, and didn't match the actual theory. ๐Ÿคฆโ€โ™‚๏ธ โ€” No Frame (75/100)

At 15:35

He's openly confessing his process was a mess and his 'conclusion' was wrong. Refreshing honesty, for a mortal. ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

Why this score: The speaker is transparent about the flawed process behind his initial conclusion. He explicitly states he was stressed, rushed, didn't care if things fit, and that his result didn't match the original theory. This is a direct admission of a lack of rigor, which is a rare moment of self-awareness.

Original quote: โ€œThis was purely based off of things I've heard about the Deltarune prophecy and the theory surrounding it. With the amount of time I was given, I was stressed the whole time. I would not stop talking. I was just throwing things together and I didn't really care if they fit cuz I didn't have enoughโ€ฆโ€

Presents an 'original theory' with specific, in-game evidence. โš”๏ธ โ€” No Frame (75/100)

At 16:04

He's laying out a specific game theory and backing it with an in-game mechanic. That's how you build a case, even if it's just for a game. ๐ŸŽฎ

Why this score: The speaker clearly outlines an alternative theory regarding Deltarune characters and provides a specific, verifiable piece of in-game evidence ('only Noelle can equip swords and the monster in the prophecy panel is holding a sword') to support it. This is a straightforward presentation of a theory and its basis.

Original quote: โ€œThe original Deltarune theories that I was supposed to match or come close to was Noelle is the monster and Susie is the girl. This theory is supported by the fact that only Noelle can equip swords and the monster in the prophecy panel is holding a sword.โ€

claims the Roaring Knight is a 'fusion' using wild speculation โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 16:59

Claiming a 'fusion' based on three pictures is peak fan-theory confidence without actual logic ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: The speaker is making a massive leap from minimal visual evidence to a specific, complex identity claim. It's high-confidence speculation masquerading as a conclusion.

Original quote: โ€œI came to the conclusion that the Roaring Knight is a Steven Universe fusion between Asriel Dreemurr and December Holiday.โ€

uses a joke to validate a theory that's mostly guesswork โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 17:37

Calling a theory 'real' just because it's 'less complicated' is doing some heavy lifting with words ๐ŸŽญ

Why this score: He uses the 'reality' of a character to validate his own thought process, using loaded comparisons to make his speculative reasoning sound more grounded than it actually is.

Original quote: โ€œThe original theory was as real as the roaring knight. A little less complicated. I had thought that December Holiday has to be a part of it because of my previous knowledge of the Dess is knight theory.โ€

concludes that the entire community is just 'crazy' theorists โ€” Just Vibes (50/100)

At 18:09

Just calling the fandom 'crazy' to end a segmentโ€”it's more of an opinionated vibe than a real claim ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: This is the speaker's subjective take on the community. It doesn't lack evidence; it just lacks a real argument, serving as a stylistic exit rather than a factual point.

Original quote: โ€œWe don't know that's Gaster. I'm actually going to split these up... Deltarune theorists, you're crazy.โ€

claims Gaster created Deltarune based on Twitter and dialogue hints โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 18:50

Building a massive conspiracy theory on a single line of dialogue and some old tweets ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: He's taking extremely thin, speculative evidenceโ€”a single word of 'possession' and some social media breadcrumbsโ€”and treating it like a smoking gun for the entire game's creation.

Original quote: โ€œI came to the conclusion that W. D. Gaster, this guy, is the one who made survey program and in turn the entirety of Deltarune. I came to this conclusion because Gaster, before Deltarune's release, talked through Toby's Twitter account. Also, in the game, the voice speaking to us, which isโ€ฆโ€

Blaming corporate structure for creative output via emotional framing โ€” Emotional Button (45/100)

At 21:02

Uses the 'struggling worker' narrative to pivot from content quality to corporate guilt ๐ŸŽญ

Why this score: He's using the emotional weight of 'unhappy workers' to justify why content might be failing, turning a production critique into a moral argument about company culture.

Original quote: โ€œThese workers need time to work or the videos will become half to pay. We shouldn't blame or hate any of the writers, Tom, the editors, or any other host. It's not their fault. I am so absolutely sure that they want to make something that they are proud of, but they can't for one reason or theโ€ฆโ€

Defensive disclaimer about not 'defaming' the company โ€” Confidence Mismatch (45/100)

At 22:19

Claims they aren't 'defaming' the company right after a massive critique ๐Ÿšฉ

Why this score: The entire segment was an indictment of the business model, so claiming 'we aren't trying to defame them' is a massive pivot in confidence that doesn't match the preceding words.

Original quote: โ€œA game theory. Thanks for watching again. Hi guys, I'm AJ. I'm the one that did a lot of the research for this video. Um and I just wanted to say uh we're not trying to defame Lunar X in any way.โ€

Claims no intent to defame Lunar X while citing 'publicly available' sources โ€” Loaded Language (45/100)

At 22:30

Using the 'we aren't defaming them' shield while actively critiquing their business model ๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ

Why this score: The speaker uses the language of 'non-defamation' as a safety net, but the entire premise of the video is a critique of the company. It's a classic defensive frame to soften the blow of a roast.

Original quote: โ€œfor this video. Um and I just wanted to say uh we're not trying to defame Lunar X in any way. If Bruce is smart, he put I gave I put the sources in the document I sent him, so he better put them somewhere in the video. Uh but they are publicly available sources.โ€

Repeats the 'not defaming' stance as a closing disclaimer โ€” Volume Game (45/100)

At 22:48

Doubling down on the disclaimer to hide the sting of the critique ๐Ÿ’€

Why this score: Repeating the same 'not defaming' line at the very end is a loud attempt to manage reputation right as the viewer is leaving, trying to make the critique feel 'safe' rather than aggressive.

Original quote: โ€œWe're not trying to defame the company in any way. Um but yeah, enjoy the video.โ€

See the full analysis with timestamps โ†’