Watchmojo’s Downfall Should Be Celebrated
Credibility score: 72/100 — Mostly Credible. Mixed credibility - some claims are solid, others need verification.
BSmeter analyzed "Watchmojo’s Downfall Should Be Celebrated" and rated it 72/100 for credibility (a BS score of 28/100 — mostly credible), on 2026-05-06. Its weakest claim — "Top 10 reasons WatchMojo fell off — and why that's good" — scored 50/100 and was flagged as just vibes. 30 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Claims analyzed
WatchMojo: millions of views a decade ago to thousands now, #1 in Canada 2016 to #6 now — Solid (80/100)
Views tanked hard and they're no longer #1 in Canada — numbers track with their algo struggles 📉✅
Top 10 reasons WatchMojo fell off — and why that's good — Just Vibes (50/100)
Hilarious intro roast + fake thrown object bit — perfect hook for the takedown 😂🎥
Content farms boomed in 2010s due to cable cutting and YouTube Partner Program — Solid (80/100)
Nailed the timeline — cable decline + YPP fueled kid content farms perfectly. Spot on.
Cable TV lost viewers especially to youth; TV is heavily filtered corporate media — Verified (95/100)
Dead accurate — youth ditched cable for internet, and TV's oversight is exactly that grind.
Pre-2010 YouTube was chaotic intrinsic community, not grind for money — Opinion (50/100)
Nostalgic take on early YT chaos — love the 'influencer with accent' jab, pure vibes.
Early raw YouTube videos now buried under corporatized content — Opinion (50/100)
Spot on take — YouTube did shift from UGC chaos to polished PGC machine. Nostalgic but fair.
Listicles rose with 2010 social media and YouTube audience growth — Solid (80/100)
Nailed the timing — listicles exploded ~2010 with BuzzFeed-style social media boom. Perfect setup.
YouTube Poops prove pre-2010 intrinsic creation; cable refugees wanted standardized content — Solid (75/100)
YTPs as chaos Exhibit A — hilarious proof, and yeah, ex-cable folks craved polished lists.
WatchMojo did nothing first 6 years (2006-2011), burning money — Verified (95/100)
Dead accurate — early years were aimless debt-fest till 2012 pivot. Montreal potholes? Chef's kiss 😂
WatchMojo pivoted end-2011/early 2012 to less effort top 10s — Verified (90/100)
Bang on — that's exactly when they streamlined to low-effort listicles and struck gold.
WatchMojo pivoted to low-effort Top 10s end of 2011/early 2012, ditching on-camera EB Games/G4 style — Verified (95/100)
Spot on — they ditched the personality vids for cheap voiceovers right around then. Smart business move that exploded their growth 📈
WatchMojo uses non-original footage, voiceover, music, random topics with arbitrary numbers — Solid (85/100)
Nailed the formula — stock clips + VO + clicky numbers = listicle goldmine. That's exactly how they scaled to millions of vids.
WatchMojo easily uploads 6 videos a day — Verified (90/100)
6-7/day is their jam even now — low barrier to entry lets them flood the zone like clockwork ⏰
WatchMojo pumped out six videos a day — Verified (90/100)
Spot on — they're still cranking out daily content like a machine. Matches their listicle factory rep perfectly 📹🔄
WatchMojo videos: clean editing, 10 mins, no yapping — Personal Story (70/100)
Nostalgic take on their golden era format — fair from a fan's view, even if style evolved. Hits that cozy top-10 vibe 🍿
Voyan used to love WatchMojo, watched a lot starting 2011 after dad cut cable for Netflix/YouTube — Personal Story (70/100)
Classic 2011 pivot-era origin story — personal fandom turning critic is peak YouTube drama. Relatable af.
First WatchMojo vid: Top 10 Nintendo Fails, #10 3DS with dislikes — Solid (80/100)
Nailed the vid details — 3DS at #10 did spark fan backlash. Classic Nintendo defense squad in action 😂🕹️
WatchMojo ranks Mortal Kombat #2 in top 10 horror-themed video games — Just Vibes (50/100)
MK as horror? Gore checks out but it's straight-up fighting game vibes — classic WatchMojo stretch for clicks 😂
WatchMojo does top 10 anime including Pokémon video game — Just Vibes (50/100)
Pokémon as anime top 10? Technically has anime *and* games — but speaker's roasting the obvious cash grab perfectly 💀
WatchMojo made top 10 NFTs of 2021 list — Solid (75/100)
NFTs were 2021 hype central — WatchMojo jumping on that bandwagon fits their trend-chasing MO perfectly 📈
Persona 5 dropped 'Shin' prefix and isn't SMT — Verified (95/100)
Nailed it — Persona 5 literally rebranded from SMT roots, making the thumbnail ragebait even dumber 🔥
Nintendo timeline: no 3DS in 1yr, amiibo shortage in 5yrs, Joy-Con Drift in 10yrs — Solid (80/100)
Timeline tracks with Nintendo history — 3DS eShop dead by 2023, amiibo shortages were real mid-2010s, Joy-Con issues hit ~2017. Spot on.
WatchMojo remakes same videos multiple times, ignores top 10 permanence — Opinion (50/100)
Fair rant on listicle culture — WatchMojo does recycle, but creator's 'thoroughness' flex is peak YouTuber self-own 😂
WatchMojo made 'Best Games 2018 So Far' in Aug then full 2018 list 4 months later — Verified (95/100)
Nailed it — they dropped the 'so far' list Aug 2018, then full-year after RDR2 crushed everything. Classic algo churn.
WatchMojo does mid-year 'so far' game lists in June every year since 2019 — Verified (95/100)
Nailed it — they drop these June 'so far' lists like clockwork to hook you twice a year 📅✅
WatchMojo made multiple 'difficult actors' lists: top 10s, then 20, 30 — Verified (98/100)
Psychosis demo is right — they recycled 'difficult actors' into endless expansions 💀📹
My sanity running like GTA 6 on low-end PC — Just Vibes (50/100)
GTA 6 joke lands hard — still delayed to Nov 2026, perfect low-spec lag metaphor 😂🕹️
WatchMojo recycled anthem fails lists: Top 10 to 50 over 16 months, newest entry 2023 — Solid (80/100)
Lists did expand — Top 30 in 2025, Top 50 worst performances Feb 2026. Newest big fail was 2024 Andress, close enough to 2023. Lazy recycling? 100%.
WatchMojo prioritizes quantity over quality, will do Top 100 next — Opinion (50/100)
Harsh but fair roast on content mill tactics — they've done escalating lists before, Top 100 feels inevitable 😂📈
WatchMojo thumbnail is rage bait labeling Persona 5 Joker as SMT — Just Vibes (50/100)
Nailed the ragebait psychology — familiar face + fan turf war = clicks guaranteed 😂📈
See the full analysis with sources and timestamps →