Why Do People Hate 3D So Much? - A Look At Studio Ghibli And Anime
Credibility score: 55/100 — Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.
BSmeter analyzed "Why Do People Hate 3D So Much? - A Look At Studio Ghibli And Anime" and rated it 55/100 for credibility (a BS score of 45/100 — mixed credibility), on 2026-09-23. Its weakest claim — "Hollywood is obsessed with making everything dark, dramatic, and realistic, unlike Eastern studios which aren't forced into a monolithic ideal." — scored 20/100 and was flagged as false equivalence. 29 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Of 29 claims analyzed: 1 scored under 40, 19 between 40 and 69, and 9 at 70 or above.
Claims analyzed
Speaker clarifies pronunciation of 'Ghibli' — a common point of discussion. — No Frame (75/100)
At 0:00
Just a quick, relatable intro about how to say 'Ghibli' — no real framing here, just setting the scene.
Why this score: The speaker is just acknowledging a common point of confusion or debate (the pronunciation of 'Ghibli') before diving into the main topic. It's a neutral, conversational opening that builds rapport without pushing any particular agenda or perspective. It's not trying to persuade or mislead, just to clarify.
Original quote: “hello let's talk about studio ghibli
or ghibli some people call it ghibli
apparently
i call it ghibli”
Claims negative reaction to 'Earwig and the Witch' trailer is 'overwhelmingly' due to 3D animation. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 0:06
Using 'overwhelmingly' to describe the reason for dislike is a strong, loaded word — it implies near-unanimous agreement.
Why this score: The speaker uses the word 'overwhelmingly' to characterize the reason for the negative reception of the 'Earwig and the Witch' trailer. While the 3D animation was certainly a significant factor in the backlash, 'overwhelmingly' suggests that it was almost the *sole* reason, or at least the dominant one to an extreme degree. This is loaded language because it amplifies the impact of that single factor, potentially downplaying other possible criticisms (like story, character design, or overall artistic direction) that might have contributed to the less-than-hyped reaction. A more neutral…
Original quote: “so a short while ago
ghibli dropped a trailer for the newest
film earwig in the witch and personally
i'm quite excited i always look forward
to ghibli films
but looking at the comments on the
trailer people don't seem to be as hyped
for this film as you would expect when
you hear anyone talk about…”
Comparing Ghibli's popularity to Disney's, calling it 'Japanese Disney' — a common but potentially misleading comparison. — False Equivalence (45/100)
At 0:30
Using 'Japanese Disney' as a shorthand for Ghibli's popularity, even while acknowledging it's 'not fair.'
Why this score: The speaker uses a common comparison ('Japanese Disney') to establish Ghibli's popularity, but immediately flags it as 'not fair.' This is a classic false equivalence, using a familiar, but not perfectly accurate, comparison to quickly convey a concept. It frames Ghibli through a Western lens, potentially overlooking its unique cultural impact.
Original quote: “like really love kipley almost as much as some people like disney to the point where it's even referred to as the japanese disney which you know isn't fair to it but”
Expressing surprise at negative 3D comments for Ghibli, citing Disney's successful 3D films like 'Tangled' and 'Moana' as a counterpoint. — Missing Context (45/100)
At 0:40
Compares Ghibli's 3D reception to Disney's, but misses the specific 'anime' context that might explain the difference.
Why this score: The speaker points out that Disney successfully transitioned to 3D with films like 'Tangled' and 'Moana,' implying Ghibli's 3D reception should be similar. This comparison, while valid on the surface, misses the specific cultural and aesthetic expectations viewers might have for 'anime' and Ghibli's traditional 2D style, which is a key part of the community's criticism (as seen in the comments).
Original quote: “it was quite surprising to see comments like this considering the mouse house did a similar thing and people still seem to enjoy the films i mean look at how many people love tangled moana”
Highlighting a top comment claiming 3D animation is causing 2D to 'die out' — framing a common fear. — Straw Man (45/100)
At 1:01
The speaker sets up a strong, easily refutable claim ('2D dying out') from a comment to then argue against it.
Why this score: The speaker quotes a comment suggesting 3D animation is causing 2D to 'die out.' This is a classic straw man technique: taking an extreme, easily disproven argument (even if it's from a comment) and setting it up as the main point of contention, allowing the speaker to then easily knock it down. It simplifies the nuanced debate about 2D vs. 3D into an 'either/or' scenario.
Original quote: “one of the top comments that apparently it's causing 2d to quote unquote die out”
Citing feedback from 'a few discord servers' and 'a Facebook group' as representative of Ghibli fans' opinions. — Anonymous Authority (45/100)
At 2:03
Relies on anecdotal feedback from unspecified 'few people' in online groups, lacking broader statistical weight.
Why this score: The speaker bases their understanding of fan sentiment on responses from 'a few discord servers' and 'a Facebook group.' While this provides some insight, it's a limited and self-selected sample. The framing here uses 'anonymous authority' (unnamed individuals in specific online communities) to support a general claim about fan opinions, without providing the scale or methodology needed for broader applicability. It's not necessarily false, but it's not robust evidence.
Original quote: “so i asked around on a few discord servers and on a facebook group dedicated to all things ghibli for people's thoughts on the new film just from the trailer and the few people that responded to me seem to say pretty similar things”
Nostalgia drives 2D preference — a relatable emotional appeal. — Emotional Button (75/100)
At 2:32
Tapping into the 'good old days' feeling to explain preference for 2D animation. It's a common, understandable human tendency.
Why this score: The speaker frames the preference for 2D animation, especially Ghibli's, as primarily driven by nostalgia. This is a classic 'emotional button' technique, appealing to shared childhood memories and a longing for 'simpler times.' It's a valid point, but it emphasizes emotion over other potential factors like artistic merit or specific aesthetic preferences, which could also contribute to the dislike of 3D.
Original quote: “a lot of the hesitance seems to come from the nostalgia factor a lot of people around my age and older grew up with the classic 2d disney films so it's very understandable that people want studio ghibli to preserve that practice because it harks back to our childhoods”
3D is the Western standard, Ghibli's 2D relevance is 'remarkable' — setting up a contrast. — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:45
States a widely accepted industry trend and then highlights Ghibli as an exception. Straightforward observation.
Why this score: This statement frames the current animation landscape by establishing 3D as the dominant standard in Western children's films. By calling Ghibli's continued 2D relevance 'remarkable,' the speaker sets up a clear contrast, highlighting Ghibli's unique position. This is a fairly neutral framing, presenting an observable fact and a reasonable interpretation without obvious manipulation.
Original quote: “especially in recent years in the west 3d animation is more or less now the standard for big screen children's films and the fact that ghibli has maintained relevance while still doing 2d is pretty remarkable quite honestly”
Nostalgia is a 'guarantor for success' for some, but has 'limits' — a balanced perspective. — No Frame (75/100)
At 3:03
Acknowledges the power of nostalgia in media while also noting its inherent limitations. A fair and balanced take.
Why this score: The speaker presents a balanced view on nostalgia, acknowledging its power as a 'guarantor for success' for some studios, but immediately tempering that with the caveat that 'such things do have their limits.' This framing avoids overstating the case for nostalgia and shows a nuanced understanding, which is a sign of good, unmanipulative framing.
Original quote: “with some studios nostalgia is almost a guarantor for success though that said such things do have their limits”
Ghibli avoids 'cash grab sequels' or 'beating a dead horse' — painting them as artistically pure. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 3:08
Uses strong, negative terms like 'cash grab' and 'beating a dead horse' to contrast Ghibli with other studios. It's a value judgment.
Why this score: Here, the speaker uses 'loaded language' to elevate Studio Ghibli. Phrases like 'cash grab sequels' and 'beating a dead horse for profit' are highly pejorative and imply that other studios are driven purely by greed, while Ghibli maintains artistic integrity. While Ghibli's reputation for quality is well-deserved, this framing creates a moral superiority, making Ghibli seem uniquely pure compared to a broadly painted 'other studios' without specific examples or context for those other studios' creative choices.
Original quote: “and ghibli by comparison to a lot of studios tend to set themselves apart as having certain standards when it comes to the projects it takes on meaning they don't waste their time on cash grab sequels or beating a dead horse for profit which i think plays into their appeal”
2D animation is expensive, listing out all the costs and potential budget hacks — highlighting financial burden. — No Frame (75/100)
At 3:32
Breaks down the tangible costs and potential budget drains in 2D animation. It's a factual explanation of production challenges.
Why this score: The speaker frames 2D animation as inherently expensive by detailing the numerous resources required (pencils, paper, software, animators) and the budget impact of revisions. This is a straightforward, informative framing that explains the financial realities of the industry. It's not manipulative; it's providing context for why studios might consider alternatives.
Original quote: “the world of animation is an expensive one with 2d you need pencils paper desks scanners animation software and of course the animators and that's just the supplies we're not even going into the different jobs or aspects of the production necessary to make something of high quality also if you…”
Hand-drawn 2D is 'far more expensive' than cutout animation, citing examples — clarifying cost differences. — No Frame (75/100)
At 4:03
Clearly differentiates between two 2D animation styles and their cost implications, with relevant examples. Informative and accurate.
Why this score: This segment provides a clear and informative framing by distinguishing between hand-drawn and cutout 2D animation, explicitly stating that hand-drawn is 'far more expensive.' The use of well-known examples like 'Avatar: The Last Airbender' for hand-drawn and 'My Little Pony' for cutout animation helps illustrate the point effectively. This is a neutral, educational framing that adds valuable context to the discussion of animation costs.
Original quote: “Different styles of 2d also have different requirements and costs hand-drawn animation which is normally what you see in films anime and shows like avatar the last airbender is far more expensive than cutout animation which is what you see in lower budget productions such as my little pony fairly…”
3D software like ZBrush and Maya are 'astronomical' and require 'beefy computers' — highlighting high entry barriers. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 4:18
Uses 'astronomical' and 'beefy' to emphasize the high cost and technical demands of 3D animation. It's an emotionally charged description.
Why this score: The speaker uses 'loaded language' like 'astronomical' to describe the prices of 3D software (ZBrush, Maya) and 'beefy computer' to describe hardware requirements. While 3D animation certainly has high costs and technical demands, these words are chosen to evoke a sense of extreme expense and difficulty, potentially making 3D seem more daunting than a neutral description would. It frames 3D as prohibitively expensive and technically challenging, which, while true to an extent, uses hyperbole to make the point.
Original quote: “with 3d there's a lot of prep work involved and the prices for software such as zbrush and maya are just astronomical and not only that you need a beefy computer to run them on let alone make anything that looks decent”
Speaker claims their Totoro model has a huge file size they can't optimize without paying for another program. — No Frame (75/100)
At 4:31
Personal experience with software limitations — totally fair to share their own struggle.
Why this score: This is a personal anecdote about their specific experience with 3D modeling software and a particular file. It's not a general claim about 3D animation, but rather a relatable struggle for anyone who's dealt with large files and software limitations. It's presented as their own challenge, not a universal truth, which is clean framing.
Original quote: “blender that my laptop is beginning to struggle and that's because this totoro model has a huge file size that i can't optimize”
Speaker says 3D makes you feel poor and they're only using ZBrush to get their money's worth from an old license. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 4:42
Using 'really poor' is loaded language to describe the cost of 3D software — it's expensive, but that framing is a bit dramatic.
Why this score: The phrase '3D makes you feel really poor' is loaded language. While 3D software can indeed be expensive, framing it this way is an emotional appeal rather than a neutral statement of fact. It exaggerates the financial burden to evoke a stronger reaction from the viewer. A more neutral framing would simply state that 3D software and equipment can be a significant investment.
Original quote: “yeah 3d makes you feel really poor the only reason i'm using zed brush is because i bought a permanent license ages ago when i had money and i just want to get my money's worth”
Speaker claims Studio Ghibli closed after Miyazaki retired because they couldn't cover expenses without him. — Missing Context (45/100)
At 5:26
Ghibli didn't 'close' in the way implied; they paused production. Important distinction for a studio of that caliber.
Why this score: The claim that Studio Ghibli 'had to close' after Miyazaki retired is a significant oversimplification and misses crucial context. While Miyazaki's retirement did lead to a temporary hiatus in feature film production and a restructuring of the studio, it did not 'close' entirely. The studio continued to manage its intellectual property, work on smaller projects, and eventually resumed feature film production. Framing it as a 'closure' due to an inability to cover expenses without Miyazaki creates a more dramatic, but less accurate, picture of the studio's situation at the time.
Original quote: “coming back around to ghibli when miyazaki retired the studio had to close because without him they felt that they couldn't make films successfully enough to cover their expenses”
Speaker acknowledges Miyazaki is working on 'Earwig and the Witch' and that their previous statements are speculation. — No Frame (75/100)
At 5:38
Full credit for clearly stating their claims are speculation and providing a relevant factual update. Good transparency.
Why this score: This is an example of clean framing. The speaker explicitly states that their previous comments are 'speculation' and advises the viewer to 'take what I'm saying with a pinch of salt.' They also provide a factual update about Miyazaki's work on 'Earwig and the Witch,' which directly addresses and contextualizes their earlier speculative remarks about Ghibli's future without him. This transparency builds trust and allows the viewer to assess the information with appropriate caution.
Original quote: “also please note miyazaki is working on earwig and the witch and a lot of what i'm saying is speculation so you know take what i'm saying with a pinch of salt this will no doubt cause friction”
Anime has changed a lot in 5-20 years, with 3D anime like Land of the Lustrous and Beastars taking audiences by storm. — No Frame (75/100)
At 6:41
This is a pretty straightforward observation about the evolution of anime and the success of specific 3D titles. No real framing tricks here.
Why this score: The speaker is making a general statement about the changing landscape of anime, citing specific examples like 'Land of the Lustrous' and 'Beastars' as successful 3D anime. This is a common and verifiable observation within the anime community. It's a fair assessment of the current state of things, not trying to manipulate or omit context.
Original quote: “but anime isn't the same as it was 20 years ago it's not even the same from 5 years ago in the last couple of years there have been some fantastic anime coming out that are 3d land of the lustrous and b stars have taken audiences by storm half i think because they have great stories and half…”
claims Eastern animation avoids realism compared to the West — using a comparison frame — False Equivalence (50/100)
At 6:56
Comparing entire regions' artistic philosophies is a massive stretch — it's more about studio-specific goals than 'East vs West' 🌎
Why this score: The speaker is making a broad cultural generalization about 'the West' vs 'the East' to explain technical failures in early 3D. This ignores the fact that many Western studios use stylized animation (like Sony) and many Eastern studios still chase hyper-realism. It's a simplified narrative to explain why old 3D looked 'off'.
Original quote: “one thing i love about eastern 3d animation is that they don't seem to have such a hang up about making things realistic like they do in the west and i do believe that line of thinking is what led those early 3d props to look so off”
Eastern 3D animation avoids Western realism hang-ups, treating 3D more like traditional animation. — Missing Context (45/100)
At 6:56
Paints a broad stroke about 'Eastern' vs 'Western' animation styles — oversimplifies a complex industry with diverse approaches.
Why this score: The speaker is framing the difference between Eastern and Western 3D animation as a clear dichotomy: Eastern embraces cartoon physics, Western obsesses over realism. While there's some truth to different aesthetic preferences, this is a generalization. Both 'East' and 'West' have a huge range of styles, from hyper-realistic to extremely stylized. Attributing 'hang-ups' to an entire region's animation industry without acknowledging the vast diversity within it is a form of missing context, as it ignores the many counter-examples that exist on both sides.
Original quote: “One thing i love about eastern 3d animation is that they don't seem to have such a hang up about making things realistic like they do in the west and i do believe that line of thinking is what led those early 3d props to look so off like yeah we can animate talking animals and fantasy worlds but…”
Eastern 3D animation avoids realism hang-ups, unlike Western 3D which rarely treats it like 'animation'. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 6:56
Uses 'hang up' and 'rarely treats it like animation' to subtly diminish Western 3D, implying a flaw without concrete examples.
Why this score: The phrase 'hang up about making things realistic' is loaded language that frames Western animation's approach as a flaw or an unnecessary constraint. Similarly, saying Western 3D 'very rarely treats 3D animation like... well animation' is a subjective judgment presented as a general truth. It sets up a dichotomy where Eastern animation is implicitly superior for its less realistic approach, without fully exploring the artistic intentions or diverse styles within Western 3D animation. It's a rhetorical choice to make Eastern animation look better by comparison.
Original quote: “One thing i love about eastern 3d animation is that they don't seem to have such a hang up about making things realistic like they do in the west and i do believe that line of thinking is what led those early 3d props to look so off like yeah we can animate talking animals and fantasy worlds but…”
Compares Disney's 'hesitant' animation in Frozen to Sony's 'zany' Hotel Transylvania, noting Disney's lack of cartoon physics for main characters. — Cherry-Picked (45/100)
At 7:11
Picks two specific examples to support a broad generalization about animation styles, ignoring the vast diversity within both studios.
Why this score: The speaker cherry-picks 'Frozen' and 'Hotel Transylvania' to illustrate a point about animation styles. While these examples do show different approaches, it's a very narrow selection to draw broad conclusions about entire studios like Disney and Sony, or 'Western 3D' as a whole. Disney, for instance, has a wide range of animation styles beyond 'Frozen,' including more cartoony approaches in other films or shorts. By focusing on these two, the speaker frames the argument to highlight a specific contrast that supports their earlier point about realism, potentially overlooking counter-examples…
Original quote: “this is kind of hard to explain but the best example i can give is look at how disney animates characters in frozen compared to how sony animates characters in hotel transylvania obviously these are big companies and they're going to have their own signature styles but there are some things that…”
Compares Disney's 'Frozen' (hesitant on cartoon physics) to Sony's 'Hotel Transylvania' (zany, stretchy characters) to show different 3D animation approaches. — Cherry-Picked (45/100)
At 7:11
Uses two specific examples to represent entire studio philosophies — ignores Disney's own history of cartoony animation.
Why this score: The speaker is cherry-picking specific examples ('Frozen' vs. 'Hotel Transylvania') to illustrate a broader point about animation styles. While 'Hotel Transylvania' is indeed very expressive and 'Frozen' is more grounded, this comparison doesn't fully represent the range of either studio, let alone 'Western' animation as a whole. Disney, for instance, has a long history of highly stylized and cartoony animation (e.g., 'The Emperor's New Groove', many shorts). Focusing on just these two films to make a sweeping statement about their 'hesitancy' to use cartoon physics is a selective use of…
Original quote: “this is kind of hard to explain but the best example i can give is look at how disney animates characters in frozen compared to how sony animates characters in hotel transylvania obviously these are big companies and they're going to have their own signature styles but there are some things that…”
contrasts Disney and Sony animation styles — using specific examples as a frame — Cherry-Picked (65/100)
At 7:15
Using two specific studio styles to represent all of Western animation is a classic cherry-pick 🍒
Why this score: While the observation about Disney's 'stiffer' character models vs Sony's 'zany' physics is valid for those specific films, it uses two outliers to represent a massive industry. It ignores the huge spectrum of Western animation styles that fall in between, making it seem like a binary choice.
Original quote: “is look at how disney animates characters in frozen compared to how sony animates characters in hotel transylvania... whereas disney is very hesitant to make characters limber or give them actual cartoon physics unless they're a side character”
claims Hollywood obsesses over realism and drama — using a 'phenomenon' frame — Missing Context (55/100)
At 7:43
calling it a 'Hollywood obsession' ignores the massive market for stylized/unrealistic animation 🎭
Why this score: The speaker is framing Hollywood's trend toward realism as an 'obsession,' but fails to mention that this is often driven by market demand for high-fidelity CGI in mainstream cinema. It also ignores the existence of highly stylized Western animation that isn't 'dark or dramatic,' making it seem like a universal rule.
Original quote: “it becomes especially evident when you look at anime films like lupin iii or even earwig in the witch it's an interesting little phenomenon hollywood seems to have this obsession with making everything darker and more dramatic and by extension realistic than it probably needs to be”
Hollywood has an 'obsession' with making everything dark, dramatic, and realistic, unlike Eastern studios. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 7:43
Uses 'obsession' to paint Hollywood's creative choices negatively, implying a lack of artistic freedom or diversity.
Why this score: The word 'obsession' is loaded language that carries a negative connotation, suggesting an unhealthy or excessive preoccupation. By stating Hollywood has an 'obsession' with making things 'darker and more dramatic and by extension realistic,' the speaker frames these creative choices as a flaw or a limitation, rather than a stylistic preference or a response to market demands. This contrasts with the implied freedom of 'Eastern studios,' which are presented as not having this 'monolithic ideal forced onto them,' creating a biased comparison without fully exploring the reasons behind…
Original quote: “it becomes especially evident when you look at anime films like lupin iii or even earwig in the witch it's an interesting little phenomenon hollywood seems to have this obsession with making everything darker and more dramatic and by extension realistic than it probably needs to be whereas eastern…”
Hollywood is obsessed with making everything dark, dramatic, and realistic, unlike Eastern studios which aren't forced into a monolithic ideal. — False Equivalence (20/100)
At 7:49
Pits 'Hollywood' against 'Eastern studios' as if they're monolithic entities with singular goals — ignores vast diversity within both.
Why this score: This is a classic false equivalence. The speaker is creating a binary opposition between 'Hollywood' and 'Eastern studios,' implying that Hollywood has a singular, monolithic obsession with 'darker and more dramatic' realism, while Eastern studios are free from such constraints. This ignores the incredible diversity of content and artistic approaches within both 'Hollywood' (which encompasses many studios, genres, and styles) and 'Eastern studios' (which includes animation from Japan, Korea, China, etc., all with their own distinct trends and pressures). It's an oversimplified generalization…
Original quote: “hollywood seems to have this obsession with making everything darker and more dramatic and by extension realistic than it probably needs to be whereas eastern studios don't really have that monolithic ideal forced onto them as much i don't think”
Claims the 'average person' only watches Ghibli for kids — a broad generalization. — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 8:35
Uses 'average person' to make a sweeping statement about audience motivation without any data. It's an assumption, not a fact.
Why this score: This is a classic example of using 'the average person' or 'most people' to present an opinion as a widely accepted truth. It's a generalization that simplifies a diverse audience into a single, convenient stereotype, lacking any actual evidence or survey data to back it up. It frames Ghibli's appeal in a very narrow, almost dismissive way.
Original quote: “the average person will usually only watch one of their films to entertain a kid”
Asserts 2D films are 'dated' for younger audiences — a subjective opinion presented as fact. — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)
At 8:44
States 'that's just the fact' about 2D films being 'dated' by younger audiences, but it's a subjective take, not a universal truth.
Why this score: The speaker presents a subjective observation ('2D films are viewed as dated by younger audiences') with the absolute certainty of a fact ('that's just the fact'). While some younger audiences might prefer 3D, it's a huge leap to declare 2D universally 'dated' without any supporting evidence like surveys or market research. It's a confidence mismatch between the claim and the lack of objective proof.
Original quote: “and yes unfortunately 2d films are viewed as stated by younger audiences these days”
See the full analysis with timestamps →