The numbers are in, and they are ugly.
Credibility score: 43/100 — Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Read it with healthy skepticism.
BSmeter analyzed "The numbers are in, and they are ugly." and rated it 43/100 for credibility (a BS score of 57/100 — mixed credibility), on 2026-11-17. Its weakest claim — "Claims a 67% rise in assaults — loaded language and framing" — scored 35/100 and was flagged as loaded language. 6 claims were checked against the post's caption and on-screen text. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the post's text, not independent human verification.
Of 6 claims analyzed: 1 scored under 40, 5 between 40 and 69, and 0 at 70 or above.
Claims analyzed
Presents hate crime increase as 'ugly' and a specific failure. — Loaded Language (45/100)
Starts with 'ugly' to set a negative tone before even presenting the numbers. The framing is clear: this is bad news.
Why this score: The opening line 'The numbers are in, and they are ugly' immediately injects a strong negative judgment before any data is shared. While the numbers themselves (52 incidents up from 34) are presented factually, the initial framing primes the audience to view them as inherently catastrophic, rather than allowing the audience to interpret the data themselves. It's a classic emotional button press.
Original quote: “The numbers are in, and they are ugly. Hate crimes on the basis of s*xual orientation in New York City reached 52 incidents in the first nine months of this year, up from 34 in the same period last year.”
Directly attributes the rise in hate crimes to Mamdani's 'watch' and broken promise. — Missing Context (45/100)
Blames Mamdani directly for the rise, implying sole responsibility without considering broader factors or his actual power.
Why this score: The statement directly links the rise in hate crimes to 'Mamdani's watch' and his promise of a safe city, creating a direct causal link. This framing omits the complex socio-economic factors that contribute to hate crime statistics, which are rarely under the sole control of one individual or mayor. It's a classic political attack, simplifying a complex issue into a personal failure.
Original quote: “That is a rise of nearly 53 percent, and it happened on Mamdani’s watch, in the city he promised would be safe for everyone.”
Presents increased funding as a failed solution, implying a lack of effectiveness. — False Equivalence (45/100)
Suggests increased funding should immediately stop hate crimes, ignoring the time lag for prevention efforts.
Why this score: This segment creates a false equivalence by implying that an 800% increase in funding should have immediately prevented the attacks from climbing. It ignores the reality that prevention programs often take time to show results, and that correlation (funding increased, attacks still rose) does not equal causation (funding caused attacks to rise, or funding was ineffective). It's a rhetorical move to dismiss the mayor's efforts as a failure without allowing for the natural timeline of policy impact.
Original quote: “The mayor’s answer is money. His budget increased hate crime prevention funding by more than 800 percent, and the attacks kept climbing anyway.”
Claims 800% funding boost failed to stop attacks — cherry-picked data — Cherry-Picked (45/100)
Dropping a massive '800%' stat without context to make the result look like a failure 📉
Why this score: The post uses a single, massive percentage increase to create a sense of inefficiency. It ignores whether the 'attacks' are rising due to better reporting, different definitions, or other variables, using the number solely to trigger a sense of failure.
Original quote: “His budget increased hate crime prevention funding by more than 800 percent, and the attacks kept climbing anyway.”
Uses '52 confirmed crimes' to mock the process — emotional button — Emotional Button (40/100)
Using a specific number like '52' to make the argument feel more personal and tragic 💔
Why this score: By citing a specific, low number of 'confirmed' crimes in a short window, the post attempts to make the viewer feel the weight of the 'failure.' It's designed to provoke an emotional reaction against the administration rather than provide a statistical overview.
Original quote: “Mamdani told the city to trust the process, and the process produced 52 confirmed hate crimes against gay New Yorkers in nine months.”
Claims a 67% rise in assaults — loaded language and framing — Loaded Language (35/100)
Using 'RISEN' in all caps and a nickname to drive home the outrage 📢
Why this score: The use of 'RISEN' in caps and the derogatory nickname 'Mamdummy' is pure rhetorical manipulation. It frames a statistical increase as an undeniable catastrophe to trigger high-intensity political sentiment.
Original quote: “Assaults against g@y couples in NYC have RISEN 67% under Mamdummy”
Sources: Claims of huge rise in assaults against ICE drive responses, but aren’t seen in available data, How Progressive Prosecutors Are Manipulating Crime Data, White House claims “more than 1,000%” rise in assaults on ICE agents, data says otherwise : NPR
See the full analysis with sources →