The Simpsons is Bad Again
Credibility score: 54/100 — Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.
BSmeter analyzed "The Simpsons is Bad Again" and rated it 54/100 for credibility (a BS score of 46/100 — mixed credibility), on 2026-06-06. Its weakest claim — "Video opens with a highlight reel preview of the Simpsons season 37 take" — scored 50/100 and was flagged as just vibes. 23 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Claims analyzed
Video opens with a highlight reel preview of the Simpsons season 37 take — Just Vibes (50/100)
Teaser sets up the big reveal that he got the new season wrong — the actual stakes come right after this.
Says Twitter consensus was that The Simpsons isn't good again and the take isn't deep — Personal Story (50/100)
His read of the backlash — people saying it didn't improve and the take was overthinking it — matches what the comments here are still echoing.
Says he always tries to find something to enjoy in any media — Opinion (50/100)
Fair approach — most critics skip this step and go straight to dunking.
Only liked one joke in all of season 37 — the Ralph mirror line — Opinion (50/100)
One-joke verdict is brutal but personal taste isn't up for debate.
Claims season 37 feels rushed with no time for proper writing — Opinion (50/100)
Classic late-season complaint — hard to prove without writers' room access.
Recent Simpsons seasons feel rushed due to lack of time — Opinion (50/100)
Classic 'they ran out of time' take — explains why jokes land flat without blaming talent.
Writing for The Simpsons remains highly competitive despite show's reputation — Opinion (50/100)
Fair point — even declining shows keep prestige that attracts top comedy writers.
Episodes use first jokes that come to mind due to time pressure — Opinion (50/100)
The 'first draft energy' diagnosis — explains why menopause episode lands on Botox immediately.
Marge menopause episode uses time jump and focuses on aging fears — Just Vibes (50/100)
Solid premise setup — universal fear of aging applied to eternally-young character like Marge.
Menopause episode defaults to cheap Botox jokes about women aging — Opinion (50/100)
Calls out the most obvious punchline winning by default — feels like deadline comedy.
Episode relies on multiple Botox and frozen face jokes about aging — Opinion (50/100)
Lazy pile-on detected — one obvious joke stretched across the whole town instead of developed.
Says one recent Simpsons episode was among the season's better ones — Opinion (50/100)
Pure taste call — no fact to check, just one fan's ranking of season 35.
Describes a Chalmers episode about giant snails and failed skincare line — Just Vibes (50/100)
He's summarizing the plot beats — the 'nothing' judgment is the real reaction here.
Calls the K-pop episode one of the season's weakest, compares it to Trap — Opinion (50/100)
Another ranking — 'flattest' is his judgment, not a measurable stat.
Says the Bumblebee Man episode is 'okay' relative to a weak season — Opinion (50/100)
Context-dependent praise — he likes it more because everything else is worse.
References old episode showing Bart isn't academically gifted — Verified (85/100)
Bart's gifted-class flop is canon — the show made it crystal clear he doesn't do traditional smarts.
Bart is street-smart and witty, not book-smart or academically gifted — Opinion (75/100)
Classic Bart breakdown — the show spent decades making this distinction, so the take lands.
Manosphere episode is the season's worst and just recycles headlines without saying anything — Opinion (60/100)
Calling it the worst is subjective — but "headline-of-the-week" syndrome is a very common complaint about recent Simpsons.
Recent Simpsons episode had literally nothing worth watching or discussing — Opinion (50/100)
Calling an episode 'nothing' is fair if it didn't land — but 'nothing there' is still an opinion, not a measurable fact.
Simpsons should stop doing headline-based stories and focus on character-driven plots — Opinion (50/100)
Classic 'go back to character stories' take — shared by tons of fans who want the show to feel like the old seasons again.
After 37 seasons it's extremely hard to find new story ideas — OK (75/100)
37 seasons is real — the 'nothing left to do' feeling is understandable but not literally proven.
Personal ratings: Season 34 = 6.1/10, Season 35 = ~7/10 — Personal Story (50/100)
These are his own ratings, not universal scores — valid as personal opinion, not objective data.
Gave season 4.5/10, episodes range 2-6 — Opinion (50/100)
Personal scores on recent Simpsons — no universal scale exists so it's just his take.
See the full analysis with sources and timestamps →