Why I Respect Asmongold
Credibility score: 46/100 β Mixed Credibility. Several questionable claims detected. Watch with healthy skepticism.
BSmeter analyzed "Why I Respect Asmongold" and rated it 46/100 for credibility (a BS score of 54/100 β mixed credibility), on 2026-09-23. Its weakest claim β "Blaming tech is like blaming guns for shooters β a heavy-handed analogy" β scored 20/100 and was flagged as sketchy. 10 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Of 10 claims analyzed: 1 scored under 40, 8 between 40 and 69, and 1 at 70 or above.
Claims analyzed
Video opens with a highlight reel preview of political commentary π β Just Vibes (50/100)
At 0:00
Teaser montage of heavy political rhetoric and 'annoying people' π¬
Why this score: The intro uses a rapid-fire clip of intense, almost apocalyptic political phrasing to set the stakes before even saying what the video is about.
Original quote: βYou know what I'm going to I'm going to this episode, I'm going to explain why I [ __ ] with Asmongold. And the the the annoying people on here who I'm going to talk about that actually after, but let's take a look at this this first clip with Asmon. >> process would even be [music] complete, theβ¦β
Sources: Politicians Funny Videos | TikTok, Politics News | Breaking Political News, Video & Analysis-ABC News - ABC News, Easy Political Commentary Video Generator Online for Free | FlexClip
Blaming tech is like blaming guns for shooters β a heavy-handed analogy β Sketchy (20/100)
At 0:47
Comparing smartphone addiction to a shooting rampage is a massive leap in logic π«
Why this score: He's equating the passive consumption of data-driven algorithms to the active, violent use of weaponry. It's a massive logical stretch used to make his point feel more 'weighty'.
Original quote: βI don't I I totally disagree with this. I think phones are a tool, and if you can't control a tool in a proper way, and you overuse a tool, then that's the individual's fault. I think blaming everything on computers and technology is like blaming a gun for why somebody goes on a shooting rampage.β
Sources: Stop Blaming Silicon Valley and Smith & Wesson for Parenting Failures | RealClearPolitics, The Philosophy of the Technology of the Gun - The Atlantic, Why do people seem to blame the thing rather than the person? - Quora
Dismissing previous points as BS and pivoting to a historical correction β Confidence Mismatch (45/100)
At 2:25
Uses 'BS' as a blunt weapon to pivot into a historical lecture π
Why this score: He uses high-confidence, aggressive language ('that's BS') to shut down the previous speaker before pivoting into a historical fact about class struggle. It's more of an emotional pivot than a reasoned rebuttal.
Original quote: βI think that's BS. I really do think that's BS... The French Revolution was not the poor people against the rich people. It was the merchant class against the nobility class.β
claims human nature is inherently divisive and cites Aristotle to back it up β Anonymous Authority (45/100)
At 2:31
He's using 'Aristotle said it' as a shield for a pretty heavy worldview ποΈ
Why this score: He attributes the concept of 'natural slaves' to Aristotle but hedges with 'I think it was,' using ancient philosophy to validate a cynical view of modern class struggle without actual academic rigor.
Original quote: βeven in the instances where people create these fantasies of, you know, the workers taking over it's actually just one side of the workers killing the other side of the workers for one side of the rich people that want to kill the other side of the rich people. This is the way that humanity is.β¦β
predicts his audience will act like 'lowlife degenerates' on social media β Loaded Language (45/100)
At 3:26
Calling his own viewers 'lowlife degenerates' is a hell of a way to build rapport π
Why this score: He uses aggressive, derogatory labels like 'lowlife degenerate' to frame the inevitable internet discourse. It's a defensive maneuver disguised as an observation.
Original quote: βI already know there's going to be a lowlife degenerate on here that's going to take that extremely out of context and probably make a Twitter post out of it.β
claims the audience is to blame for why he respects Asmongold β Emotional Button (45/100)
At 3:48
Turning the blame back on the audience is a classic psychological trap π
Why this score: He uses the 'it's your fault' pivot to create an emotional confrontation with his viewers, using their own potential biases as the reason for his stance.
Original quote: βthey you guys ask me like how can I watch someone who doesn't like your kind or wishes you were dead and all this other stuff. And you know, you want to know why? It's because of you. Like it's it's your fault.β
Accusing critics of using out-of-context clips to lie β Missing Context β Missing Context (45/100)
At 4:49
Calling out the 'clip culture' trap. He's pointing at a tactic, not providing proof of it here π©
Why this score: He's identifying a specific way people manipulate content (decontextualized clips) to build a case against someone, but he's doing it as a general observation rather than showing the specific clips he's talking about.
Original quote: βAnd I think you do an absolute disservice when you take out of context clips and try to paint it as someone's entire world view. I'm not one of those people.β
Blaming the audience's bias for calling him a racist β Emotional Button β Emotional Button (45/100)
At 5:43
Turning the mirror on the viewer. It's a psychological jab to make you question your own judgment π
Why this score: He uses the audience's preconceived notions (the 'he is a racist' label) to create an emotional confrontation, making the viewer feel responsible for their own bias rather than debating the facts of Asmongold's actual political stances.
Original quote: βBecause of you. Because you you told me that he was a racist and he was all these other things, and I had to go and look for myself. So, you can blame yourself for whatever you whatever is wrong...β
Advising intellectual humility during debates β No Frame β No Frame (75/100)
At 6:12
Just some straight-up advice on not being a narcissist during a debate. No tricks here, just truth π
Why this score: This is a direct philosophical stance on how to approach discourse. It's not trying to manipulate the viewer into an emotion; it's a straightforward call for open-mindedness.
Original quote: βAnd I think the best thing you can do to yourself is just consider you may be wrong about everything you're going to go about having a quote-unquote debate about. Consider that you may be wrong and the other person may be right.β
Comparing social media users to 'slaves' using loaded metaphors β Loaded Language (45/100)
At 7:07
Using 'slavery' to describe scrolling through TikTok is a massive reach π
Why this score: The speaker takes the heavy concept of slavery and applies it to digital consumption habits. It's high-drama framing that lacks any actual structural comparison to real slavery, relying on emotional weight rather than logic.
Original quote: βare some people meant to be slaves? Yeah. But it's not just like that... It's like slave to your phone, slave to TikTok, slave to Instagram, slave to YouTube...β
See the full analysis with sources and timestamps β