The new M5 Max/Ultra Mac Studios are INSANE! #apple #mymac #macstudio #tech
Credibility score: 71/100 — Mostly Credible. Mixed credibility - some claims are solid, others need verification.
BSmeter analyzed "The new M5 Max/Ultra Mac Studios are INSANE! #apple #mymac #macstudio #tech" and rated it 71/100 for credibility (a BS score of 29/100 — mostly credible), on 2026-09-28. Its weakest claim — "Comparing unified memory to dedicated GPU memory, then adding a 'to be fair' that changes everything. 🍒" — scored 20/100 and was flagged as cherry-picked. 26 claims were checked against the video transcript. Scores are produced by BSmeter's AI analysis of the transcript, not independent human verification.
Of 26 claims analyzed: 1 scored under 40, 4 between 40 and 69, and 21 at 70 or above.
Claims analyzed
Claims the old M1 Max is 'ridiculously fast' based on personal speed tests — Personal Story (60/100)
At 0:00
Using his own export speed as a benchmark for 'ridiculously fast' 💀
Why this score: He's basing the power of the chip on his own workflow. It's a personal experience, not a lab test, but it's his reality.
Original quote: “This right here is a 4K 30 FPS video being exported on a Mac Studio with an M1 Max chip and you can see it's moving along pretty quick. 64 65 can we get 66. There wego. Every video that I've made since I bought this Mac Studio has been able to be exported faster than real time. The M1 Max chip is…”
Claims Apple's constant progression necessitates the new M5 chips — No Frame (75/100)
At 0:18
Just stating the obvious: tech moves and new chips exist. No tricks here 🤷♂️
Why this score: He's just setting the stage for why he's talking about new hardware. It's a straightforward transition to the actual topic.
Original quote: “But of course time keeps moving forward and so does Apple and we now have an M5 Max and an M5 Ultra chip. Now just to be clear, I'm not going to be reviewing the M5 Max. I'm going to run the M1 Max until that”
Claims his old M1 Max is still sufficient for current workflows — No Frame (75/100)
At 0:30
Just stating his personal use case. No tricks here, just a guy refusing to upgrade 💀
Why this score: He's setting expectations early. It's a personal workflow claim rather than a technical benchmark, so it lands as an honest premise.
Original quote: “not going to be reviewing the M5 Max. I'm going to run the M1 Max until that thing is no longer supported by Apple because it is still fast enough.”
Comparing M1 Max to M5 Max specs, then shutting down obvious counter-arguments. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 0:46
He's just excited about the new tech, even if he knows it's an unfair comparison. — Acknowledges the obvious, then dismisses it for the sake of hype. 🔥
Why this score: The speaker is openly comparing a four-generation-old chip to a brand new one, fully aware that the performance leap is expected. He pre-emptively dismisses the 'obvious' criticism, framing it as pure appreciation rather than a serious technical comparison. It's a transparent move to indulge in the 'wow' factor without pretending it's a fair fight.
Original quote: “I have the bin version but this has 18 CPU cores and 40 GPU cores. And like to anyone who's going to go to the comments and point out like well obviously it's four generations newer of course it's going to have all these crazy new features. Shut up. I just like appreciating it compared to what I…”
Comparing M1 Max to M5 Max specs, then preemptively dismissing criticism. — No Frame (75/100)
At 0:46
He's just appreciating the raw numbers, not making a direct 'better value' claim — and he knows it. Fair enough. 😈
Why this score: The speaker acknowledges the obvious generational leap, so he's not trying to trick anyone into thinking it's a direct, fair comparison. He's just marveling at the progress.
Original quote: “I have the bin version but this has 18 CPU cores and 40 GPU cores. And like to anyone who's going to go to the comments and point out like well obviously it's four generations newer of course it's going to have all these crazy new features. Shut up. I just like appreciating it compared to what I…”
Bragging about new specs while dismissing the obvious generational leap. 😈 — Volume Game (45/100)
At 0:46
He's hyping the new cores, then immediately telling you to shut up if you point out the obvious. That's not appreciation, that's a preemptive strike. 💀
Why this score: He's presenting the raw numbers as if they're a shocking revelation, then quickly dismissing the most logical counter-argument before anyone can make it. It's a classic move: make a big claim, then quietly undercut any reasonable skepticism. He wants the awe, not the context.
Original quote: “I have the bin version but this has 18 CPU cores and 40 GPU cores. And like to anyone who's going to go to the comments and point out like well obviously it's four generations newer of course it's going to have all these crazy new features. Shut up. I just like appreciating it compared to what I…”
Dismisses the memory increase as a 'not huge' bump — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:02
Calling a jump from 32GB to 36GB 'not huge' is actually being incredibly honest. No hype 📈
Why this score: He avoids the typical tech-enthusiast trap of pretending every incremental upgrade is a revolution. It's grounded.
Original quote: “the new one starts at 36. Not a huge bump but still pretty cool.”
Compares memory bandwidth across generations with technical specs — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:14
Just throwing numbers at the wall. No emotional fluff, just raw bandwidth data ⚡
Why this score: He's providing specific comparative metrics. While he uses the word 'crazy', it's backed by the actual bandwidth figures provided.
Original quote: “the M5 Ultra was 800 GB per second. Those were already some pretty crazy numbers thanks to how Apple does their like chip scaling but then you get to the M5 Max. The M5 Max is 614 GB per second.”
M5 Max memory bandwidth at 614 GB/s, acknowledging it's slower than M1 Ultra. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:19
He's giving specific numbers and even notes a downgrade from an older, higher-tier chip. This is just straight data. 🔥
Why this score: The speaker provides a specific, verifiable technical specification for the M5 Max's memory bandwidth. He also offers a direct comparison to the M1 Ultra, noting where the M5 Max falls short, which adds to the transparency. This is a straightforward presentation of facts.
Original quote: “but then you get to the M5 Max. The M5 Max is 614 GB per second. Not as fast as the M1 Ultra but still crazy.”
The M5 Max's memory bandwidth is 'crazy' — but slower than the M1 Ultra. 🚩 — Confidence Mismatch (45/100)
At 1:19
He calls 614 GB/s 'crazy' for the M5 Max, then admits it's slower than the M1 Ultra's 800 GB/s. That's not 'crazy,' that's a downgrade. 💀
Why this score: The speaker uses 'crazy' to describe a number that is, by his own admission, a step backward from a previous generation's 'Ultra' model. The enthusiasm doesn't match the actual data point, creating a false sense of awe where there should be a question mark. It's like calling a smaller slice of cake 'crazy good' when you just had a bigger one.
Original quote: “but then you get to the M5 Max. The M5 Max is 614 GB per second. Not as fast as the M1 Ultra but still crazy.”
M5 Max memory bandwidth is 614 GB/s, not as fast as M1 Ultra. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:19
He's stating a specific spec and comparing it directly to a previous gen. — The numbers are out there, no trickery here. 😈
Why this score: The speaker is providing a specific technical specification (M5 Max memory bandwidth) and making a direct, verifiable comparison to a previous generation (M1 Ultra). This is a straightforward factual statement about product specifications.
Original quote: “but then you get to the M5 Max. The M5 Max is 614 GB per second. Not as fast as the M1 Ultra but still crazy.”
M5 Max memory bandwidth is 614 GB/s, less than M1 Ultra. — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:19
He's stating the M5 Max's bandwidth and admitting it's not the top dog, which is a rare moment of honesty. 😈
Why this score: The speaker is providing a specific technical specification for the M5 Max and directly comparing it to a previous generation's higher-tier model, noting where it falls short. This is a straightforward factual statement.
Original quote: “but then you get to the M5 Max. The M5 Max is 614 GB per second. Not as fast as the M1 Ultra but still crazy.”
M5 Ultra memory bandwidth is 1.2 TB/s. — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:27
Another specific number, no spin. I'm almost bored by the lack of deception. Almost. 😈
Why this score: This is a direct, verifiable technical specification for the M5 Ultra. It's presented as a raw number without additional framing or comparison at this exact moment.
Original quote: “But the M5 Ultra 1.2 TB per second of memory bandwidth.”
M5 Ultra memory bandwidth is 1.2 TB/s. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:27
Another direct spec claim for the M5 Ultra. — Just the numbers, no spin. 🔥
Why this score: This is a direct, specific claim about the memory bandwidth of the M5 Ultra chip. It's a technical specification that can be verified against product announcements and reviews.
Original quote: “But the M5 Ultra 1.2 TB per second of memory bandwidth.”
M5 Ultra system memory rivals dedicated GPU memory like the 4090. — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:35
He's comparing the M5 Ultra's unified memory to dedicated GPU memory, and the numbers actually back him up. A rare sight. 😈
Why this score: The speaker provides specific, verifiable bandwidth numbers for the 5090 and 4090 GPUs, then draws a direct comparison to the M5 Ultra's unified memory bandwidth. The comparison is quantitative and appears accurate based on the provided figures.
Original quote: “For reference, the dedicated video memory in a 5090 runs at 1.79 TB per second. The 4090 on the other hand runs at 1.01 TB per second. The M5 Ultra Mac Studio has system memory that rivals dedicated GPU memory.”
Comparing M5 Ultra memory to dedicated GPU memory, claiming it 'rivals' it. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:35
He's making a direct, verifiable comparison of bandwidth numbers. — The math is right there, even if the architectures are different. 😈
Why this score: The speaker provides specific, verifiable memory bandwidth figures for the NVIDIA 5090 and 4090 GPUs, then compares them to the M5 Ultra. While the architectures (unified vs. dedicated memory) are different, the raw bandwidth numbers are being presented accurately for comparison. The claim that it 'rivals' is a subjective interpretation but based on the presented data.
Original quote: “For reference, the dedicated video memory in a 5090 runs at 1.79 TB per second. The 4090 on the other hand runs at 1.01 TB per second. The M5 Ultra Mac Studio has system memory that rivals dedicated GPU memory.”
Comparing unified memory to dedicated GPU memory, then adding a 'to be fair' that changes everything. 🍒 — Cherry-Picked (20/100)
At 1:47
He says M5 Ultra 'rivals dedicated GPU memory' then immediately adds the crucial caveat that it's *unified* and *shared*. That's not a rival, that's a different beast entirely. 🚩
Why this score: The speaker makes a direct comparison between the M5 Ultra's unified memory and dedicated GPU memory, implying parity in performance or function. However, he then quickly adds the critical distinction that unified memory is shared, which fundamentally changes how it performs in real-world scenarios compared to dedicated VRAM. It's a classic bait-and-switch: highlight a flattering comparison, then bury the inconvenient truth that undermines it.
Original quote: “The M5 Ultra Mac Studio has system memory that rivals dedicated GPU memory. Now to be fair, that memory is unified system memory so it is shared with the GPU but you can get up to 512 GB of it.”
M5 Ultra's unified memory rivals dedicated GPU memory, up to 512GB. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:47
He's making a bold claim about unified memory, then immediately adding the crucial context about it being shared. That's a fair assessment. 💀
Why this score: The speaker makes a strong claim about the M5 Ultra's memory performance but immediately follows it with the necessary context that it's unified and shared. This provides a balanced view, acknowledging both the impressive capacity and the architectural difference from dedicated GPU memory. It's a transparent comparison.
Original quote: “The M5 Ultra Mac Studio has system memory that rivals dedicated GPU memory. Now to be fair, that memory is unified system memory so it is shared with the GPU but you can get up to 512 GB of it.”
M5 Ultra unified memory up to 512GB, 5090 dedicated GPU memory capped at 32GB. — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:50
He's highlighting the difference between unified and dedicated memory, and the capacity numbers are specific. No trickery here. 😈
Why this score: The speaker is explaining a key architectural difference (unified vs. dedicated memory) and providing specific, verifiable capacity numbers for both the M5 Ultra and the 5090. This is a straightforward technical comparison.
Original quote: “Now to be fair, that memory is unified system memory so it is shared with the GPU but you can get up to 512 GB of it. Meanwhile, while the 5090 does have some incredibly fast GPU memory, it is capped at 32 GB, which is insane for video memory, but again, it's only video memory. This can be shared…”
Highlighting M5 Ultra's 512GB unified memory vs. 5090's 32GB dedicated memory. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 1:50
He's accurately pointing out the difference in memory architecture and capacity. — A fair distinction, even if it's a bit of a flex. 🔥
Why this score: The speaker is accurately describing the difference between Apple's unified memory architecture (shared, high capacity) and traditional dedicated GPU memory (separate, lower capacity). He acknowledges the trade-offs and benefits of each, providing a balanced, albeit enthusiastic, comparison.
Original quote: “Now to be fair, that memory is unified system memory so it is shared with the GPU but you can get up to 512 GB of it. Meanwhile, while the 5090 does have some incredibly fast GPU memory, it is capped at 32 GB, which is insane for video memory, but again, it's only video memory. This can be shared…”
Claims the M5 Max can handle 19 streams of 8K ProRes — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:24
Dropping a massive spec at the end to show why it's overkill. No lies detected 🎥
Why this score: He is citing the specific high-end capability of the new chip as a contrast to his own modest needs. It's a factual performance ceiling.
Original quote: “Meanwhile, while the new M5 Max is talking about playing up to 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS.”
M5 Max can play 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:26
This is a specific performance claim, likely from Apple's marketing. — A benchmark claim, not a personal opinion. 🔥
Why this score: The speaker is citing a specific performance metric, likely from Apple's official specifications or marketing materials for the M5 Max. This is a verifiable claim about the chip's capabilities under specific workloads.
Original quote: “the new M5 Max is talking about playing up to 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS.”
M5 Max handles 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS. 😈 — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:26
That's a specific, verifiable performance claim. No fluff, just numbers. 🔥
Why this score: The speaker states a clear, quantifiable performance metric for the M5 Max. This is a direct claim about the chip's capabilities, which can be verified through benchmarks or official specifications. It's a straightforward technical detail.
Original quote: “the new M5 Max is talking about playing up to 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS.”
M5 Max can play 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS. — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:26
A specific performance claim for the M5 Max. It's a bold number, but it's a number. 😈
Why this score: This is a specific, high-performance claim about the M5 Max's video editing capabilities. While impressive, it's a quantifiable metric that can be tested or verified against Apple's stated specifications.
Original quote: “the new M5 Max is talking about playing up to 19 streams of 8K ProRes at 30 FPS.”
claims $2,500 is 'impressive' despite a $500 jump — Loaded Language (45/100)
At 2:41
Calling a $500 price hike 'impressive' is just selling the hype 💸
Why this score: He acknowledges a significant price increase but immediately uses 'impressive' to soften the blow. It's classic marketing fluff to make a higher entry point feel like a steal.
Original quote: “the starting price for the M5 Max Mac Studio is $2,500, $500 more than what the Mac Studio used to be, but still pretty impressive performance for the price.”
the Ultra chip costs $5,500 and high RAM is delayed — No Frame (75/100)
At 2:50
Straight facts on the steep price and the waiting game for high RAM 💀
Why this score: He's just giving the raw numbers here. No tricks, no emotional fluff—just telling you that it's expensive and the high-end specs are delayed. Pure information.
Original quote: “But the M5 Ultra chip, number one, just switching to it makes it $5,500. And unfortunately, we won't have 512 gigs until October.”
See the full analysis with timestamps →